Shane Long scored a late equaliser to deny Saints a league double over second-placed Reading at St Mary’s following David McGoldrick’s opener.
Jan Poortvliet made two changes to the side that lost at Plymouth on Boxing Day with the experienced Chris Perry coming into the side at the expense of Olly Lancashire, who dropped down to the bench, and Matt Paterson was handed his first senior start in place of Andrew Surman who picked up an ankle injury late in the game at Home Park.
Reading’s Noel Hunt was only fit enough to take a place on the visitors’ subs bench following an injury he suffered in their recent win at Birmingham, but the Royals were still able to field a very attack-minded line-up with Kevin Doyle, Shane Long and Stephen Hunt all playing from the start. Second-choice keeper Adam Federici, who scored Reading’s 96th-minute equaliser against Cardiff on Friday, retained his place in the continued absence of Marcus Hahnemann.
Saints, as has often been the case this season, started brightly with Paterson and David McGoldrick linking up to good effect through the middle and Lee Holmes and Rudi Skacel teaming up on the left flank. Ryan Smith was also seeing a lot of the ball on the other side, but Reading had clearly watched him carefully at Plymouth as he was often faced by at least two defenders who were happy for him to keep the ball out wide on the right rather than allow him to cut inside onto his favoured left foot.
Reading were surprisingly trying to play very direct in the first half, looking for flick-ons by Doyle from long balls, and it came as no real shock that they made very little use of them. They did, however, look dangerous on the rare occasions that they managed to get the ball out wide. Stephen Hunt caused Lloyd James a few problems and Skacel had to be alert and brave to make a headed clearance at the far post when he knew he was inevitably going to be on the end of a hefty challenge straight afterwards, for which he earned a free-kick. James also showed that his defensive awareness is improving with every game as he raced around in front of Hunt at the far post to clear Marek Matejowski’s curling cross to safety.
The best chance of the first half fell midway through the half. From one of Saints’ many corners, the ball fell kindly to McGoldrick on the penalty spot and his snap shot certainly didn’t lack power as it smashed against the underside of the crossbar, which was probably still shaking five minutes later.
Reading were starting to get frustrated, and this was reflected by bookings for Doyle and Matejowski for cynical late challenges on James and Simon Gillett respectively shortly before half-time.
Ryan Smith, of whom I’d been singing the praises in the pub before the game after his excellent performance at Plymouth, was replaced after a pretty disappointing first half by Bradley Wright-Phillips.
Saints continued at the pace they’d been setting in the first half and some desperate defending and perfectly-timed tackles by Michael Duberry and Ivar Ingimarsson came between McGoldrick, Paterson and Wright-Phillips and the Reading goal.
Ten minutes into the second half, Lee Holmes was replaced with Kayne McLaggon, who had made his senior debut at Plymouth and looked lively, and he slotted in wide on the right-hand side.
On the hour, Paterson had a great chance to score his first senior goal as a deep cross by James found him unmarked on the edge of the area but his side-footed volley didn’t have enough power to trouble Federici who made a comfortable save. That was to be Paterson’s last action of the game as he was replaced by Jason Euell in an attempt to inject a bit more pace and power up front.
Reading made a double substitution replacing Matejowski and Brynjar Gunnarsson with James Harper and Kalifa Cisse in the heart of their midfield. This seemed to actually give Saints a bit of a boost as they both took a little while to get into the game, and just three minutes later they took full advantage. Kayne McLaggon embarked on a determined run from inside the Saints half, evading challenges from both Harper and Cisse as well as Stephen Hunt, and then slipped a perfectly-weighted through-ball between the two centre-backs for McGoldrick to run on to. He took a touch to steady himself and then slotted the ball under Federici to make it 1-0. It was McGoldrick’s first goal in 11 games and for that reason alone he won’t have been too bothered about the yellow card he received for taking his shirt off in celebration.
Reading boss Steve Coppell made his last available substitution by replacing left-back Chris Armstrong with striker Noel Hunt in an all-out attacking move to rescue the game for the Royals. It almost paid instant dividends when Hunt won a free-kick out wide and the delivery by his brother Stephen found Duberry unmarked at the far post but his first touch was abysmal and ran out for a goal kick.
With Saints now happy to play on the counter-attack, McGoldrick and Wright-Phillips were looking to exploit the space against a three-man defence as often as possible. Wright-Phillips fed McGoldrick 25 yards out and he jinked past Ingimarsson into the area but was unable to get his shot past the covering Liam Rosenior.
A minute later, Reading’s additional pressure and attacking numbers was rewarded when Stephen Hunt’s wide free-kick was nodded down by Duberry and Long got to the ball just before the previously untroubled Kelvin Davis to nod it into the gaping goal for a barely-deserved equaliser.
It nearly got worse for Saints as Stephen Hunt was again involved. His deep cross found the head of Kevin Doyle but the ball crashed against the crossbar and away to safety. Saints immediately broke away and had a strong appeal for a penalty waved away after Duberry appeared to handle the ball in the area after McLaggon tried to engineer a bit of space for a shot. To be fair to referee Phil Crossley, his view of the incident would have been blocked by at least one player, but his assistant on the Kingsland side should have had a near-perfect view. Unfortunately, when you’re struggling, those decisions do have a habit of going against you.
With both sides going all-out for victory at the end, a lot of space was being created at either end, and Kevin Doyle almost won it for Reading in injury time when he wriggled free of Chris Perry’s attention but Davis was able to turn his shot over the bar for a corner.
That was it, and on the face of it a draw against the team in second place isn’t a bad result. However, put in context with the results obtained by Nottingham Forest and Doncaster Rovers today, it’s now left us second from bottom in the Championship. It was a decent performance today, and hopefully the players will take that as a positive rather than the late dropping of points that has now happened in two of the last three home games. That said, it makes a pleasant change to actually have a lead at home to lose, rather than just losing the game! The next two league games, at Barnsley and against Doncaster at St Mary’s, are going to be critical to our survival in this division this season.
For me, the only disappointing performance was from Ryan Smith, who was well and truly found out by a Reading defence who had done their homework. Matt Paterson led the line well in the second half but clearly tired in the second, which was reflected in the lack of power and conviction in the shot he had just before he was substituted.
David McGoldrick’s goal was just reward for a hard-working shift today, and it’s not often I’ve been able to say that about his performances this season. If he can put in the workrate like he has today, he’ll be rewarded with more goals, in my opinion. He’s shown he’s got plenty of ability, but there remain question marks over his attitude and commitment.
It was also good to see that the players can perform in front of a big crowd. The attendance of 20,142 was the second-highest of the season and, while the Forest game was a massive let-down, hopefully some of those who were there who haven’t been going to games regularly will respond to today by turning up to the Doncaster game. The United game on Sunday is obviously a big game in terms of its prestige, but we go into that game with absolutely nothing to lose, so I don’t think we should really read anything into the performance we put in or the result there.