austsaint

Wasn't just the pass though - there was the mazy run from well inside our own half which culminated in "that pass". What a great moment. Good luck to the lad - he showed glimpses of Prem quality.

No, and maybe.

I made a similar mistake - believing that Edmund Hillary could never walk on the moon; but he did. Maybe Saints will be promoted automatically this season.

I was wondering whether Russ got Mara mixed up with Edozie! Similar hair styles at the moment. If Mara was to be brought on, it had to be in place of Adams - he just can't play that wide right role. Will surely be moved on in the Summer.

He did play well. I was thinking it preferable Bree at LB, KWP on the right - yet the creative work KWP and Aribo came up with probably justified Martin's decision. Good too that we had two CBs in their correct positions. A bit of hanging on at 2-1, yet you'd have to say a deserved win. Usual suspects played well - Downes outstanding, THB, KWP also good, but Aribo's game, particularly the first 70 minutes was outstanding. He is just the creative player we need in the play offs to unlock a defence in a tight game.

Aribo very good so far. Linking up well with KWP. Has an eye for a pass.

I completely agree; Poch was a much superior Manager/Coach than Puel. I'm the last person to be influenced only by numbers and tables - they are nothing without the qualitative eye for what's happening on the field. My opinions too come from watching on TV and my once-a-year trips home. You were the one who cited points tallies, anomalies and historic table positions, not me. The thing that is beyond dispute is that at this point - Claude Puel (whose Football style I disliked) has many more runs on the board than RM. And if RM doesn't find a way to get Saints promoted from the lottery of the play offs, I doubt he will get the chance to match Puel's record. For what it's worth, I agree with your 1 to 5 table of Managers - I'd have Puel ahead of Martin - otherwise, good call.

Get back to me when RM takes a side to the EFL Cup Final and accumulates enough points to comfortably maintain Saint's Prem status.

All very well except for the small matter of Puel managing in the Prem and Martin in the Championship - very different standard of competition. As Martin will find out if he's snapped up by Brighton.

He certainly lacked quality compared to his predecessor, Ryan Bertrand. I take your point that the recruitment staff should have eyed off someone better - it's a been a trend though, hasn't it.......Ing's not replaced by equivalent quality; Romeu another example. I wasn't at the Bournemouth game - I'm a Hampshire ex-pat who gets back to the UK once a year. I think that was the game Perraud copped a serious ankle injury. I do remember him getting up and down the flank with good pace in several games; there are many wide attacking players in the Prem who will make many full-backs look short on pace. Manning superior technically? We differ there. You might recall Perraud regularly displayed a gun left foot with goals at the highest level and also high standard crosses and free kicks. You call Perraud a Championship standard player - I'd argue he was like most of our Prem side at the end of the 22/23 season - just short of Prem standard, but very likely to be very useful in the Championship - Lavia, Livramento, KWP and Ward-Prowse excepted. How do you think Manning would have gone in the Prem that season? Anyway, it's an interesting discussion. I've got a feeling that Meghoma is going to be a very good LB, and he represents the future of the Club.

Calling for captions.

You've never liked him Chez. Agree with most of your assessments, but not this one. Perraud has some pace; was technically ok at Prem level and would be a very good performer in the Championship. Not clear cut that he wanted out for any other reason than Martin didn't fancy him and had Manning in his back pocket. I don't expect him to return under any circumstances but I'm sure we would have been better off with a back four of KWP, THB, Bednarek and Perraud.

That's my recall too. Serious ankle injury from memory. Perraud may have wanted out, but Martin didn't make it easy for him when he regained fitness, with that out-of-position Cup game about his only opportunity. He was solid enough for us at Prem level, has a sweet left foot and got stuck in. As a specialist LB he would have been a real asset this season - a definite upgrade on Manning.

Particularly given the Club paid 12 million pounds for him (a bargain) in 2020. No way is KWP on 20k pw.

I made the claim before the Ipswich game that he's a better attacking mid option than WS, and I think he proved the point. Just has a greater set of skills and attributes, and speeds our attacking game up a gear. He has improved, but most of all he is like a number of our players - very good at Championship level; not quite up to it at Prem level.