S-Clarke

The 'young player' stuff being thrown around doesn't really float for me. At 21 in football terms he's not really young, plenty of players aged 20-21 have played and are playing to a high level. Tino, Lavia, Shaw, Bale, Theo, Ox, Palmer, Bellingham to name just a few. Even Edozie has given us more than Mara and he's the same age. He's not had an enormous amount of minutes, granted - so that is an argument to have for sure, but my assumption on that is that he's simply not showing enough to be considered good enough to play. He may make a career for himself but I don't see it being at a high level, he could end up going to a lower French side I reckon. Sometimes it just becomes obvious that a certain player is simply not going to make the grade.

Rotherham was a funny one, we've certainly had some frustrating games this year where we have been shit (Blackburn away, Millwall at home etc), but that Rotherham one in my memory was a total freak of a game. Play that another 9 times we win it 9 times. That game was just one of those games that everyone gets. The game that killed us this season was the Hull home game, totally knocked us off course as we then went and lost again against Millwall. Those are the 2 I will always look back on as the games which consigned us to the playoffs.

I get really nervous when we bring him on in a game that's still on the edge, as when we're up against it he's a non-entity. His showing against Cov was one of the worst I've seen, and I've seen Charlie Austin. If he ran around, made his presence felt, tracked, then we could forgive him for his many technical shortcomings - but when he doesn't do any of the 'basics' it's hard to be too downhearted that he'll be missing.

When you look at the options we have in attack, it's pretty frightening really. He's going to have to manage this lot right. Palmer, Kane, Foden, Watkins, Saka - someone is going to have to miss out! Rice and Bellingham should be the two in CM. It's at the back we have problems, the drop off in quality is stark.

Yeah I'd expect Dibling, SAA etc to step up - maybe Larios and Meghoma as well. The problem is we don't have those good youngsters to step in to fill Armstrongs boots, or Adams boots, or THB etc. The returning loans are an interesting proposition, but wages will dictate those I think. ABK has apparently already told us he'd only come back if we were promoted, so he can do one as far as I'm concernered. If we don't go up this year we will have a serious job on our hands to build a competitive squad in the summer. Should make the rumour mills fun at least, and this thread should be mega active.

100%, It's not like we're asking him to pull off worldies like that in every game - far from it, just a few a season would be nice, I'd like to see him do something that at least earns us some points - otherwise we might as well stick an outfield player in goal, could potentially be the ultimate Stephens shoe-horn position.

We would certainly have to replace the loans, but we'd have much more to do this summer should we fail. KWP, Bednarek, Adams, Armstrong (x2), McCarthy, Sulemana would all need replacing in some form as well, as there's no chance we'd retain any of those guys. We'd need at least 12 players to replace all those we'd lose (including the loans), but we'd probably need more than that in order to have a squad. Will be a tough ask without a DoF to boot! It's a bit daunting really, we'd have more of an upheaval than last summer, but we'd have less money, no DoF and no 'just relegated' advantage over the rest of the league.

Just for comparison, we are ahead on points from where we were after 41 games in 2011/12. Not by many, just a couple - we had 79 points after 41 games back then. We did manage to snatch 2nd on only 88 points though, no one got over 90 pts that year. So I reckon we can bet on us beating our 2011/12 points total for sure, but the others are all going to be in the 90's as well. Looking at the games remaining for everyone I think a fair guess is that 95/96 points will get you into the Top 2 places, anything less than that and it's playoffs. For us to get 95/96 points we need to win every game, just shows how impossible it really is. Even a single draw will stop us hitting those point tallies.

Great story for him, I'm sure this wasn't even in his wildest dreams. Those Spurs guys must have totally jinxed Bayern. I reckon the best way to stop the City juggernaut is to give them Harry Kane.

Looks like another Man City procession then. The PL has been such terrible quality this year, when you've had Forest docked 4 pts and Everton 8...and they're still not in the bottom 3 after losing most weeks, that tells you the quality up there!

Don't forget that if we do make it up, THB is an obligation signing - so he will be ours by default for around £20mish. I'd say he's a PL level player, along with KWP. I reckon we'd also sign Downes and Fraser and I'd also put them down as PL standard. Our big 'new' signings would need to be... 1st Choice GK. We cannot continue blindly with the Bazunu experiment again. He'd become the cover. 1st Choice 2nd CB - Bednarek and Stephens would become squad cover. 1st Choice LB - upgrade on manning, he'd become squad cover. 1st Choice CM - upgrade on Smallbone/Aribo in CM. 1st Choice ST - replacement for Adams etc. Goes without saying, we'd need a PL striker (or someone capable of scoring goals in the PL). If we get those 5 signings right (8 including the perm additions of THB, Fraser and Downes) through the spine then I think we have much more of a structure to enable us to get most out of some of our younger lads too. Obviously would need to sign some depth in certain areas, but I don't think the overhaul should we go up will be as much as 20 new additions. I would estimate around 10/11 new additions (including making the loans perm). I wouldn't be comfortable with anymore than that.

I think there's an issue of trust there, similar to why we see so little of SAA and Dibling in the games that actually matter. On paper he is the most natural replacement or best player to compliment Flynn in a 'closing up' period of a game, but we've never used him in that way. Rather bizarrely, if you go back to the start of the season and during pre-season, we were fixated on using him as a CB rather than CM. I'd be interested to see the stats, but I reckon he's played just as many games for us at CB which is a little odd.

I guess what they've seen from that is that he moves his position towards the ball, with his arm. Probably a somewhat natural/automatic body movement, but it gave the referee a decision to make and he probably shouldn't have gone to ground like that. I've seen much worse pens given than that.

I don't think there are any easy games in this league at this stage tbh. (apart from Rotherham). Blackburn, Milwall and Watford have shown that - two fighting, 1 in the middle of nowhere. In the weird world of this league the table has flipped, as you've got the top 4 struggling like hell with the pressure and the bottom teams thriving in the pressure.

Yeah I'd say it's done and dusted for all the chasers for the Top 6. PNE in particular are 9 points behind (inc. GD) with just 12 to play for and have to overhaul 4 above them, they're done.