Dodgest penalties awarded to saints?

[doddisalegend]

Football fans are always quick to point out penalties that their team didn't get or the dodgy penalties the opposition are awarded. But I was thinking what about dodgy penalties we have been award over the years the sort that even with your best red and white glasses on you have to say "the ref got that one wrong"


First up I'll give you Fonte against Brighton in the championship (about 1.20 in) I was at that game and I don't remember complaining about it out the time





I'm sure there must be others can anyone think of any?

[Batman]

Jrod againts Villa
He dived. Simple as that

[Pilchards]

Think Kevin Phillips in a home match when he tripped up and the ref gave it.
Was it the day we won the rugby World Cup?

[doddisalegend]

Jrod againts Villa
He dived. Simple as that

just found a clip of it that puts Vardy to shame

[kwsaint]

Football fans are always quick to point out penalties that their team didn't get or the dodgy penalties the opposition are awarded. But I was thinking what about dodgy penalties we have been award over the years the sort that even with your best red and white glasses on you have to say "the ref got that one wrong"


First up I'll give you Fonte against Brighton in the championship (about 1.20 in) I was at that game and I don't remember complaining about it out the time





I'm sure there must be others can anyone think of any?

The weird thing about the Brighton game was that there were two stonewall penalties that weren't given, and two dodgy ones that were. Lambert went down fairly easily for the second one that was given, having previously been wrestled to the ground by a defender and getting nothing. Brighton were a horrible niggly Gus Poyet side at the time and the ref never really had control of the game.

We also got two penalties at Millwall the same season, the second of which was a handball by a very young Harry Kane. Wondered if that ref ever went back to the Den.

[hans gruber]

Football fans are always quick to point out penalties that their team didn't get or the dodgy penalties the opposition are awarded. But I was thinking what about dodgy penalties we have been award over the years the sort that even with your best red and white glasses on you have to say "the ref got that one wrong"


First up I'll give you Fonte against Brighton in the championship (about 1.20 in) I was at that game and I don't remember complaining about it out the time





I'm sure there must be others can anyone think of any?

100% penalty that. 🤣

[Sergei Gotsmanov]

Think Kevin Phillips in a home match when he tripped up and the ref gave it.
Was it the day we won the rugby World Cup?

Wolves I think

[Wurzel]

Think Kevin Phillips in a home match when he tripped up and the ref gave it.
Was it the day we won the rugby World Cup?

Against Wolves? Not only tripped up it was so far outside the box think he was still outside the penalty area when he hit the ground. But hey ho, the ref gave it so it's a penalty

[Appy]

One at Watford on Tadanari Lee in 11/12, never a pen.

[Stud mark of doom]

The one against Blackburn in the last minute of luggy’s last game. 3-2 win for us.

[doddisalegend]

One at Watford on Tadanari Lee in 11/12, never a pen.

It on Tadanari's Southampton highlights youtube video (over 8 minutes long somehow ) at about 2.12 soft very very soft..

[shurlock]

Still don’t 100% know what happened for lambo’s 2nd pen at Millwall (where we came from behind to win 3- 2).

[Toadhall Saint]

Still don’t 100% know what happened for lambo’s 2nd pen at Millwall (where we came from behind to win 3- 2).

Neither do I and I was there

[revolution saint]

Still don’t 100% know what happened for lambo’s 2nd pen at Millwall (where we came from behind to win 3- 2).

From where I was it looked like Hooiveld handled the ball and instead of a freekick to Millwall the ref gave us a pen. Good day that was.

[doddisalegend]

Still don’t 100% know what happened for lambo’s 2nd pen at Millwall (where we came from behind to win 3- 2).

about 6.12 looks like Jos the boss's hand to me

[Lets B Avenue]

Didn't remember it was Harry Kane that it was given against.

Probably explains why he now scores every game against us.

[simo]

Jrod againts Villa
He dived. Simple as that

Ref for that game was Mark Halsey , Was talking about the Vardy dive against us the other week and mentioned the Jrod dive said next match he reffed us with him playing he had "A quiet word in the tunnel" haha

[Sheaf Saint]

just found a clip of it that puts Vardy to shame

It was a weird one. If he hadn't drawn his right foot away then it would have been a penalty anyway because it was a terrible challenge. But yeah, an odd one indeed.

[Stud mark of doom]

Plus there was that offside in ‘76.

[Lighthouse]

From where I was it looked like Hooiveld handled the ball and instead of a freekick to Millwall the ref gave us a pen. Good day that was.

There’s a photo somewhere of a Millwall player (not Kane, some meaty looking skinhead I think) doing a Maradona, before it got to Jos. Can’t remember but it was an absolute stone waller when you see it.

I was at the game too and didn’t see it either.

[doddisalegend]

There’s a photo somewhere of a Millwall player (not Kane, some meaty looking skinhead I think) doing a Maradona, before it got to Jos. Can’t remember but it was an absolute stone waller when you see it.

I was at the game too and didn’t see it either.

this one? yeah that certainly puts a different light on it

[Chewy]

Not the worst (j rod wins that) but the most recent i remember was the one we got opening day v West Ham a season or two back allowing us to win after we'd contrived to surrender a 2 goal lead against ten men. May have actually been a pen but remember thinking it was very soft at the time. Of course, being against the hammers I was ok with it!

[saint1977]

Three or four that stand out

- Short on Beattie in Sturrock’s last game
- Pahars v Everton early in 02/03
- R Wallace v Newcastle early 90s to end a hideous run without winning
- Saganowski v Yeovil x2

[Stud mark of doom]

Three or four that stand out

- Short on Beattie in Sturrock’s last game
- Pahars v Everton early in 02/03
- R Wallace v Newcastle early 90s to end a hideous run without winning
- Saganowski v Yeovil x2

Rod Wallace was 1 April 1989. April fools day. 20 plus games without a win. Last minute. Definite pen.

[Barsiem]

Three or four that stand out

- Short on Beattie in Sturrock’s last game
- Pahars v Everton early in 02/03
- R Wallace v Newcastle early 90s to end a hideous run without winning
- Saganowski v Yeovil x2

I seem to recall the Pahars one was when he kicked his left leg with his right one, fell over as a result and got the pen! I also seem to recall there was no defender within a yard of him! If my memory is correct, that has to be the dodgiest penno we've had in the modern era

[Ziggy]

Jrod againts Villa
He dived. Simple as that

I was in the toilet when that happened and just got back to my seat in time to see the penalty.

We had gone with a Villa mate who drove us there and she was cursing on the journey back! I could legitimately deny seeing it but my lad couldn’t stop laughing about it!

[Noodles34]

about 6.12 looks like Jos the boss's hand to me

Jesus, Lambert was a fat bastard wasnt he.