Gary O’Neil joins Bournemouth after that 9-0 defeat to Liverpool and looking dead certs to finish bottom. He kept them up and was swapped out for a huge upgrade, doesn’t mean he didn’t do a good job though.
He then kept Wolves up when it looked like it might be their turn, finishing 14th. Next season though they were playing awful footy and he was sacked. They had sold more key players but he still had Cunha playing out of his skin.
Although only 30%ish win rate, for struggling PL teams you can see he was quite effective, he did keep both sides up in those first seasons.
Saints are 19th in the championship. It’s not that the calibre of this appointment isn’t good enough (we have failed to find a manager that can keep us up after many attempts and 2 relegations), it’s more that those Portsmouth links will give him very little time to make it work and as a manager he doesn’t have Championship promotion experience.
if he did join and get us into the playoffs and winning at Fratton in January, we would all forget the link. If he started slowly we would have the toxic situation yet again. It’s a gamble.