So how are we defining star quality then? Is it goal contributions? If so Armstrong had the most in Europe last time out in the championship. I’m all for improving the forward line, especially given how blunt it was at PL level, but what is the criteria for doing so? We have 3 players, 4 including Stewart’s small sample size (but has fitness concerns) that have very good numbers at this level. What we are missing is the attributes that Downs seemingly has. The trouble we have is to get a Downs that also has a record in the championship scoring goals like Armstrong, is a player we couldn’t attract or likely afford. Some posters have suggested if we were signing a striker that has Armstrong’s record, we would be saying that’s the right type of move to get us promoted.
It’s hard to improve our striking options at this level without gambling and hoping it turns out well. With that in mind I would like to keep Armstrong and Archer around and compliment with Downs and Stewart. If we play 5-3-2 for example, the striker pairing will need a hold up, strong link player and finisher. With those 4 I think it’s a good balance of 2 players per position. If we sell any, we will replace but I doubt we get a player with a better championship record.
The ‘star quality’ forward (productive at PL level) will likely have to wait until we are promoted. I think that is the reality. You’re not signing a proven player like Mitrovic in the championship, you’d have to get relegated with him and keep hold of him as Fulham did.