i'm not saying it didnt rip of bf because it did but IMO its been everything i wanted BF to be. The feeling of being in a war, you can say what you like about you only really fight 64 players on occasion i have told my squad to help another squad take there burn offs and driven to the other side of the map.
Saying people run around like headless chickens, sure but they do this in BF as well but there is tactics, take burn off tower run in posion gas all entrances.
Or aquisition drive APC to there spawn and park in safe area wait for rest of squad to take out all road blocks,drive and hopefully your home free.
All these things i have done before so i can tell you now there is a tactical side to this game.