OldNick

Will WHU want tolet us have a player to strengthen us.............depends on your standpoint with him I suppose

and a goalscorer and so very versatile, no doubt could play the Beckenbauer role sweeping crossfield passes left right and centre, sometimes to his own players

Better than having that rat faced Cuccarella , absolute hate the thought he could win anything, complete arse of a man. The way he screamed the other day to get a foul. So Id prefer the Peacock to the rat any day of the week

I get what you are saying and feel that as well, but too many times Ive seen us go down with a whimper, not that day

Thanks for that, not the result we wanted but it was still hell of a day being there with the Saints fans

Doesnt answer the question about how the otherplayers who were here how they will feel him trotting back here. I dont rate him and so my opinion is skewed perhaps. He scored some marvellous free kicks but I can never recall him bossing any games ( apart marking the Palace player that time)> It frustrated the hell out of me how he didnt play the ball forward and make killing passes (smallbone was more effective at that)

What would the squad members who plyed with him who saw him drop us like a brick so not to face the slog of the championship think? We seem to have a pretty decent unity at present, do we want that affected

Sorry no lol, I think its Jordan James

What would the dressing room dynamics be? this needs to be taken into account if we get him back. Jack is a major figure and would he be happy to take a back seat and potentially lose his captaincy. Add to that other players who were with us when we went down and he scuttled off may resent him . As for others out there I mentioned James Justin who was superb for Leicester and scored goals. There will be gems out there that Spors may well pluck from Europe

Im surprised that you hold that position, you usually can see the better quality players, Charles IMO will go on to be a very good player. Put him with other PL players and he will grow. Time will tell and no doubt you will point out to me if he fails

A brilliant signing, a classic WHU player very flashy but often a dud

I can recall his best was under Jones when he played him in a forward role, scored 2 goals and never played him there again!!!

I never sawwhat the fuss was about him as he annoyed me with his safe sideways and back passing, ok he could take a free kick and a corner but IMHO his corners came in with such velocity it was hard for anybody to time the run

IMOa massive downgrade. JWP is sluggish on a good day. we need physical quick and strog battling midfielders not plodders who dont play forward

It is not the physique of player I thought we would go for. I thought Tonda wanted 6ft tall players who had a bit of pace. Doesnt strike me he fits that bill.