Carlos Alcaraz

[West end Saints]

I liked him and had flashes where he showed ability and tried things others wouldn't.

I liked his character and enjoyed watching him.

However, it wasn't him being adventurous which slowed his progress it was misplaced easy passes, mistimed tackles etc.

He is still young and there is a player in there, but he isn't one that I feel we have lost out on.

The RM argument fails when you see how a younger adventurous midfielder, who likes driving forward and passing forward has done so much better - in higher league, and worse team Fernandes showed more than CA.

As he gets older, more experienced he may well be a regular starter, rather than odd exciting  flashes.

I have no idea whether we pushed him out or he wanted out but we have lost dozens of better players.

[pimpin4rizeal]

21 hours ago, West end Saints said:

I liked him and had flashes where he showed ability and tried things others wouldn't.

I liked his character and enjoyed watching him.

However, it wasn't him being adventurous which slowed his progress it was misplaced easy passes, mistimed tackles etc.

He is still young and there is a player in there, but he isn't one that I feel we have lost out on.

The RM argument fails when you see how a younger adventurous midfielder, who likes driving forward and passing forward has done so much better - in higher league, and worse team Fernandes showed more than CA.

As he gets older, more experienced he may well be a regular starter, rather than odd exciting  flashes.

I have no idea whether we pushed him out or he wanted out but we have lost dozens of better players.

Even though you  talk like he was way worse then fernandes, both times alcaraz has played prem football his goals and assists have been equal or better in half the amount of games . I think there’s an argument for alcaraz being the more impactful player 

[West end Saints]

2 hours ago, pimpin4rizeal said:

Even though you  talk like he was way worse then fernandes, both times alcaraz has played prem football his goals and assists have been equal or better in half the amount of games . I think there’s an argument for alcaraz being the more impactful player 

I think we are half agreeing - CA does at times make an impact (in better sides tho) , but MF offers more,all round play and less like to have a brain fart and pass to the wrong team