Have to say I don't have massive confidence in either, but it's Forster at the moment for me. McCarthy seems shell-shocked (understandably) and so ponderous and unsure when it comes to playing it out from the back. Looks a shaky accident waiting to happen. Also, beaten too easily, too often (including on the near post). Forster has more presence and comes off the back of some clean sheets, but used to take forever to get down. Definitely think we need a new keeper in the off-season. Makes so much difference to the confidence of a back four.