-
Posts
13087 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Holmes_and_Watson
-
I tuned in and heard Darren Bent talking about Les Reed's time in charge of Charlton. He talked about this very short reign, and that he didn't score during it. He said that the team were at a low ebb, that didn't help at all. But that they looked at Les and thought he was basically a fill in, rather than anyone who would be capable of getting them out of it. With that reaction in place, it didn't go at all well. Not to mention Les' actual skill levels at that job. I was a little surprised that they then went back to Nathan Jones, which is why Reed came up apparently. Surprised in that I didn't realise this was now being discussed that widely. They mentioned a few other short lived managers and said that Jones was already a contender to go, along with Lampard. On Ralph: We played some great stuff with him in charge. It was built on an approach that was very focussed and system based. That doesn't suit all players / personalities, but there's buy in when it's going well. Ralph was unfortunate that the resources were never made available to him to progress with that system during that first period of it. It would have been sad, but understandable if he had been let go after the first slump. He was possibly fortunate that no pennies, also included pay offs. A refreshed team went on a cracking second run, again with limited resources. Ralph was again unfortunate that he had to make do. After RalphBall was found out, it would have been sad, but understandable if he had been let go at any point from the last third of last season. He, and the new owners, could look at previous success, previous bounce back, improved incoming investment, a RalphBall identity across the club. I can see why he was kept into this season, and considering what he'd done it would have been great if he had reinvented the system. But since we offered absolutely nothing during our last slump, it could just as easily have been him going with the back room staff. He did well getting an early season tune out of the side with Broja last time. This season, we lost to fine margins. We'll just not know how much the lack of getting in strikers has cost us. It would have changed not just outcomes, but shape, tactics and possession. With the club looking to trim the wage bill (which isn't a terrible thing if it can be planned well),we won't know how much he wanted to keep Romeu, or Redmond. How much he bought into the recruitment of the summer (I can recall Adams being dropped, ahead of our new attacking arrivals, as if alerting him to other clubs). And certainly about that 3 centre half mess. That lack of doing it all his own way looked to have an impact, particularly when he wasn't given what was needed. Excellent young players brought in, utterly undone by giving the team no attacking outlets, and losing one of our best in a key position. Jones has inherited a side trained to a certain style, in a set system under a certain personality. He has a different style, with players even less suited to get results from it, and with the same glaring deficiencies as before. He's not a bad person or manager in this situation. He's not wrong to take the job or believe he can turn it round. It's an uphill battle from before his first day. But going back to Darren Bent's comment, we needed someone to come in, inspire and have the depth of knowledge and experience at this level to drive through some results until reinforcements could be brought in. We did not need to risk the top level future of the club, and many employees, on someone's pipe dream of a long term project. If the club aren't going to change managers, I can only hope Jones is given the attacking options that Ralph was denied. Then we'll see if we've even got a fighting chance.
-
1) Put me in charge. 2) Although relegation would still occur, I'd be a lot happier. OR Bring in a number of players pronto. Under Ralph that would have been a finisher, Romeu's identical twin and a creative midfielder. Under NJ, it's the above, plus whatever is now needed for a direct game. Far more physical in being able to receive hoofs out wide and up front, and do something with it, plus reinforced midfield/ defence to be able to deliver those balls from deep. Targets and direct passers. OR Bring in someone more in Ralph's line, and bring in the Ralph requirements. All transfers needed pronto. OR Dither once more on transfers. Have the club wheel out how tough it is to seal a deal in the richest League on the planet. Have the manager accept blame in interviews, while actually saying it was rubbish for ages before him anyway, so it's not really his fault after all. Train yourself to move your club in the Championship column of your Shoot league tables wall chart, ahead of next season. I'm for the first option myself. 🙂
-
The host brings out a cake stand with 11 cakes on it. Everyone at the table except NJ, wants to position them in a 4-4-2 formation, to show him the error of 3 cakes at the back. Tense. 🙂
-
The team that just beat us managed to bring in 26 or so in one window. Sure, we'd have to accept paying the salaries of the ones we've got too, as it's unlikely there would be many takers. But it might be possible. Just let me have a moment to pretend it's possible at least... 🙂
-
I'd not want my memories of Adkins tarnished by seeing him have to put up with this shambles. Far better for him to host seminars for us, so supporters can get some positivity from the other parts of their lives, while we slump for the rest of the season. NJ's team would be utterly useless, but thanks to Adkins, we'd all feel so great about everything else, it would soften the blow. 🙂
-
That's not 2026/2027 mind... 🙂
-
NJ said that Adams would be a better goal scorer with him in charge. Because making strikers better goal scorers is what he does. Southampton efforts on target = 0 Under Ralph the bulk of that team learend automatisms that, before it got sussed out, gave the team an identity and passing capability that took us well into the top half. I doubt NJ's approach is more technical than that, but yet it's somehow beyond him to get whatever it is across to the players, or the players have somehow lost the ability to learn. All of them. Here, we didn't threaten a team that, compared to how long our lot have worked together, just met in the car park before the game. If NJ's plan is more direct football, then it's odd that his team never took risks, never played with any pace, never looked like wanting the ball, never looked like creating space to recieve it, never looked like holding it up and certainly never seemed capable of getting a shot on goal. There are remnants of Ralph in there, which is never going to work in a new system. But whatever that new system is, it hasn't reached the brains or feet of the players. If it exists. Against a promoted team who have had to quickly work together, who are rightly at the same end of a table and who were sitting back, after we gave away our mandatory defensive howler as a gift goal. I think I saw 1 move, where a poor ball was played to Lavia, he turned it and got a quick pass out to KWP. Nothing came from that. And it had to be done after an error, and against a team that were already dropped deep allowing us bags of possession. We didn;t look remotely capable of quick movement like that, when Forest were further up. Our centre half look fairly strong, but the rest of the tam look deicdedly lightweight against everyone else in this league. We're not going to be winning many fights. And propping up the league, every game is going to be a fight. That was as tough a watch as I can remember in a long time. NJ had a long break with this squad. The end product might not ahve been quite there, without bringing in, say, a more physical attacker. But I'd have expected to see some signs of what the plan is. NJ looks constantly surprised that L1 tactics don't work against Premier League players. The club, manager and players all knew how important these last few games were for our season. Points = 0. And nothing is exactly what they deserve.
-
Sums up the night really
-
New defender? 🙂
-
Stu! Stu! Stu!
-
By half closing my eyes, I can pretend that the team in yellow and blue is us in our away kit. It's better than watching the other clueless lot. 🙂
-
Edozie cught in possession. Just not strong enough, to do the things he thinks he's going to get away with. Forest have put in a couple of really good deliveries, that we've completely failed to manage.
-
We looked likely to make an error, even before we had to push up. But our back 3 would be really punished against a better side.
-
And again. Edozie with a chance to get a ball into the box. Chooses to go further and loses it.
-
Edozie overplays it (as he has done since his very first game). We get caught out and Forest ease right past us and nearly get a chance. Our replacements have just as many flaws, as the ones we took off.
-
Forest bringing on a new signing? A signing? surely not? If the window was open wouldn't our club have concuded brining in one of the players we've been crying out for for months? But all other clubs don;t have it as difficult in January as we do it seems. Grrrr...
-
Wow. KWP did a Redmond. A couple of better attacking passes available. But no... we might create something...but might lose the ball...too risky... stop and back pass... move breaks down and Forest get possession. Jones not putting a stamp on it at all. Salisu and Lyanco long throws were early evidence of that.
-
Physio needs to be on soon. Dean Henderson is going to need the cushion on his comfy chair adjusted soon. Lots of focus rightly on concussion, but not so much on the poor defenders and 'keepers, who fall into comas waiting for our attack to do something.
-
We're getting more possession. While it's easy to get overly enthususiastic at them stringing 2 passes together, nothing is coming of it.
-
And we're looking up to that glittering, bright point as an aspiration from how we're playing now. 🙂
-
CC with a header that was well over. But is still the closest we've come. >sigh<
-
Another mess up with our 3 at the back, got caught and allowed a shot in. tame passing. Just want rid of it, more than they want to create anything that might work.
-
cacophony of boos at half time. And that was probably polite, considering that fist 45. We looked marginally better approaching the whistle. But that's not to say we could complete a couple of passes together, or get a ball into the box, or show for a pass, or look as though we had much of a clue. It's just that Forest, being one up, dropped back a bit to take their lead into the interval. There were a couple of moments where it looked as though being more direct was where we'd be more liekly. Again, that's not to say any of those worked. But Jones' tactics are direct. With a team that offer zero threat from direct styles of play, having been trained for the last few years to play a very different style to that, and who have no personnel who look remotely likely to do anything playing that way.
-
We're showing that you could pick any random 11 players, put them up against our team, and they'd win. Very poor.
-
i thought one of the 2 forest players was going to get on the end of that, when we didn;t clear it.
