Mr X

Seems every run of 5 or more wins, we could easily follow with a run of 5 or more losses! Guess that's why we will always be a mid table at best team, but we seem even more erratic under Ralph, you just never know what you are going to get, when it clicks it clicks but when it doesn't we look very fragile, although I am not suggesting he should go

Agreed lyanco seems erratic to say the least, but has that passion & presence and aggression to his game, there is potential there if he can build up a run of games

Forgot to mention bednarek in my match assessment, he is a back up at best, why is he starting?, poor this season no positional awareness and gets beaten easily time and time again, we desperately need a better partner for Salisu!

We showed a few glimpses of what we are capable of but had no answers to a team that got plenty of people behind the ball, I don't think Newcastle were that much of a class above but our defending was shocking at times and they got lucky with a back heel strike that 99 times out of 100 wouldn't have hit the target. Tino not himself scared to beat his man. Brojas worse game you can see he's getting angry at frustrated at himself and others Dejenepo and AA tried to rally late on but again no end product from either of those. Kwp at least tried to bring the attack some great runs from him but had too little support, Armstrong the Stuart variety his usual industrious self again needs better support

But what do you think.about Newcastle?

Not our night

Ffs offside from a goal kick practically

Perraud better option than tino at the moment

Dejenepo he's class!

Too little too late in this one, need to beat Watford now

Created lots of chances for Newcastle though

The good run gave us false hope we quickly go back to the old saints when it counts

We've had glimpses of really good play but not tested their keeper anywhere near enough

take a draw all day long right now

We do over complicate stuff a lot, lots of passing without being dangerous

Not getting back in this one on this evidence! .... hopefully that's done the trick

Jesus christ we go from sublime to abysmal in the blink of an eye this team can't shake its frail mentality!

We've had the better chances now awful again

Ffs should have took our chances

Been on top last 20 mins just can't find that killer touch

Going to really tough now you have to finish teams off when you are on top

That lasted long

First touch ruined it

Wow comentators definitely on a Newcastle love in

Think we got totally complacent against villa didn't turn up and totally underestimated the opposition. Just our luck to be facing a very different Newcastle a draw would be a great result!