S-Clarke

The OS will always do that, it's not worth listening to the club propaganda during times like this as it just winds you up even more.

I feel sorry for Fellows as it's not his role, he's wasted having to run back all the time. But Manning, well, you can't say any more than has already been said! He's bad in a 4, even worse as a wing back as part of a 3. He's not quick, not strong, he panics under pressure, he can't mark, he doesn't sense danger. But he can pass with his left foot. You could wrap that description up and apply it to quite a few of our players tbf.

Armstrong isn't a striker, he's a wide forward - or an inverted forward in certain setups. He has never been consistently any good in a central position. We needed a proven CF to start the season, with Archer and Downs providing cover or alternative options. Archer playing alongside someone proven could have also been fruitful, but we'll never know.

No, because it would have still left us with Cameron Archer and Ross Stewart - and the later couldn't be relied on, so we needed 2 strikers in the summer. That was pretty obvious to anyone with eyes.

I think a better manager would look at this squad and say, yeah, I fancy my chances - but we need to do x or y to get the best out of so and so etc. But the club won't allow that to happen, it has to be done the clubs way - and that's why we only end up with the likes of Tonda. We've got a strong squad for this level, but it's not being played correctly and nor is it balanced quite right. We're many levels below what we had under RM, but we're still decent for this league - better than we are right now. So I also can't buy the 'we have loads of rubbish' players argument. We have some, yes, but there are tools to work with here - if someone is allowed to.

Like every other club in the history of football, in all other leagues, the manager appoints the staff - usually people he trusts and knows from previous roles. But as Tonda has never been a manager, he doesn't have that - so we're in a situation where the club is trying to match a coach to the manager, or should I say match a coach to the club philosophy. It's even more bonkers when you look at it.

You can only be trolling at this point, and that takes some going as a mod - credit for that. You were one of the 'Bazunu is fine for the Championship' brigade by the way. Just saying.

No, I don't give him that slack. He was all over that summer recruitment because we felt it was a good idea to not replace Wilcox. It was Martin, Bitcon and Parsons around the table with the scouts. His hands were all over the deals we made that summer.

I respect you for sticking at it and still trying to believe, but come on Manji - it's over. There's nothing left for SR here, they need to lock up and go. We can continue to hope and believe, because all we'll do is hope and believe ourselves to L2. We spent £55m in the summer which was a record amount for a Championship club, granted a lot of that was generated from the sales of Dibling & Fernandes. £60mish between both of them. Who are we selling in the summer for 30m fee's, let alone 60m combined? No one. We might get a few mill for Shea Charles for 1 year left, we may get around £15-20m for Leo if someone gambles - we might get 5-6m for THB if we sell up? We might get £15m for Ramsdale at a push? Then when you combine that reduced transfer income with a smaller parachute pot, and 3 teams coming down with PL squads and parachute pots, then it's probably fair expect us to be well off it. You can't really compare us with a Coventry or a Sunderland coming from the edges to the promotion push the next season, because those two clubs were building over time. They had a plan, they had a squad, they just had to tweak here and there. We have nothing. We are in complete freefall and have been for the last 12 months. There is no magic formula or 'positivity' that's going to fix this, it's hope casting at this point. The only 'hope casting' we should be doing is wishing for new ownership and trying to get SR as far away from this club as we can, ASAP.

I don't think he did. Gao came in under Kruger when he was in charge. The issue we had is that Kruger went back to Canada with the 5 pledges, so we'll never know what Gao's plans were for us....!

Managers appointed by SR: Nathan Jones - A failure, promoted beyond his means. a 'try to be clever' appointment when it wasn't needed. PPG - 1.07 Ruben Selles - A failure, promoted beyond his means. a 'try to be clever' appointment when it wasn't needed. PPG - 0.44 Russell Martin - I can't say he was a failure, as we got promoted under him. It was a 'try to be clever' appointment from the outset though. In the PL he was an absolute failure and we were not setup to compete in any way. Ivan Juric - A failure. He was an experienced coach (one of the only experienced they've appointed) with a specific style, the polar opposite of what Russell Martin had implemented before - so the players didn't fit, a weird call timing wise. They probably use this as justification as to why 'experience' didn't work. PPG - 0.44 Simon Rusk - A complete waste of time this one. Promoted way beyond his means, I don't believe they ever saw him as the manager - just someone to see it till the end of the season. PPG 0.29 Will Still - A failure. promoted beyond his means, and another try to be clever appointment you have to say. PPG 1.13 Tonda Eckert - A failure. Promoted beyond his means, a try to be clever appointment when it wasn't needed. PPG - 1.13 (not including his caretaker stint). Overall there is a consistent theme here - they promote and appoint people beyond their skill level, hoping to turn rough scraps into diamonds to provide THEM with an opportunity to pat their ego because they were so revolutionary. Similar themes follow throughout the coaching staff, with the likes of Ben Reeves, Ben Garner, Adam Lallana. Obviously it doesn't work, so why do they keep doing it? Because it enables control. They are able to retain the control of the narrative across the entire group. Whether that's formations, style of play, tactical approaches, transfer targets etc - with people in these roles promoted beyond their means it allows SR to assume the decision making, and the rest just nod along. Juric was the only change from that, but he wouldn't have lasted long when he discovered they wouldn't have allowed him the autonomy.

We've spent £55m this season, and we're closer to 23rd. We are 15th. Why is next season going to mean that we are more competitive than this year? We're not going to have more money to spend next year, or better players. We're going to be up against teams stronger and better than us too. Doesn't add up I'm afraid.

Great goal, good to see Reed made a good career for himself. Same as Targett really. Both were let go from us at a time when we were 'upgrading' our squad, yet they're both many many levels above what we can currently field. So, well done everyone. The blueprint of how not to run a football club since 2017!

Oh absolutely not, it's not about promotion next year - it's survival, 100%. We will not be in the promotion picture ever again with SR in charge.

The rather scary thing is that you can find another 10-20 goals of that exact standard that he lets in.