S-Clarke

We've had some pretty bad forwards, he's up there. The fact we've got £10m for him, and he's paid for a new GK, is absolutely bonkers and amazing business.

He is/was a very, very highly rated keeper. I knew he had some injury issues, but I didn't know they were as consistent as they have been. He's missed around 150 games in 4/5 years. Last season he missed 27 games. Season before 16, season before that 27 again - so yeah, undeniably he does seem incredibly injury prone (seems to be a recurring wrist injury)….but the chances of signing keepers of his level are quite rare for clubs like us, so hopefully he doesn't end up sharing the treatment room with Stewart and we can get a decent % of games from him. I imagine the fee will be quite small due to his injury history.

Not sure what's funnier with regards to that Krapyvstov link. 1) He's called Krapy 2) It's another kid who hasn't played football professionally. 3) Chelsea are linked and they already have 200000 keepers.

I don't understand how these top clubs can get the money they can for their deadwood. Before his injury and after his decent season with us (in the January when he was with us actually) there was talk of £30m bids. Now, 2/3 years on, on the back of a mega-injury and a pretty woeful spell at Fulham, he's still worth the same. Bonkers really. To me there's no value in that one, Fulham fans will vouch for that as they hated him last year. A loan with a £10-15m is probably fair, but £30m is just nonsense and is why football is broken.

An interesting interview with his Estoril manager, who will know him better than most. Solent Sport - Vasco Seabra: Saints and AFCB get transfer insight - BBC Sounds

Outside of Ramsdale, I'm not sure of any other PL keepers available for loan who'd be suitable or gettable for us. I predictably saw an article linking us to Ukraine's U19 goalkeeper, available on a free after being released by Dinipro-U19's. Hasn't ever played a pro game in his career. I imagine that one is a goer. Free - tick Young - tick Never played pro football - tick

More nonsense from the bat-shit crazy Chelsea.

It's that time of the transfer window where every single tweet, news article or rumour is taken as gospel, and we spend the next 24 hours (well, DT does) losing their minds for no real reason.

I think we'll struggle to shift ABK for any notable fee now. Hoffenheim were utter shithouses releasing the news about his heart. There's no way clubs will commit anywhere near what we want now We either take a nominal fee, or we loan him out for the rest of his contract and earn a loan fee every year. Will probably be the latter.

I find the whole Stewart thing a little perplexing really. We were told in December of 2023 that we can 'count him out' for the rest of the season, no need to put pressure on him. Then we start to hear that he may make it back for the playoffs, he does - around 20mins? That was on the pretence that it would allow him to go into pre-season with a bit of match conditioning behind him, and then attack pre-season to get up to speed. He missed the entirety of pre-season. Not just the games, but even normal training. He hasn't been seen. He may well be back on the training pitch next week, but I won't hold my breath that we'll see him kicking a ball for us to any sort of level. Honestly feels like the club are covering all tracks for some sort of insurance claim here, acting like they've done everything they can not to rush him back etc.

Sporting fans love this guy -

But if Baz hadn't got that injury, we wouldn't haven't been playing Newcastle away - probably Preston or Oxford. Swings and roundabouts really, but the reality is that not a single one of our 4 First Team GK's are good enough and won't ever be good enough for PL football, which is an absolute mess.

Just seen that Ivan Tony looks like he's off, not included in the Brentford team today due to 'transfer interest'. Brentford already replaced him with Thaigo, but he's injured for 7 months - could be a killer if he leaves.

I'd agree to a point that we're a bit bloated - Charles, Charly at a push, Sulemana, Onuachu, Mara, ABK are 6 players that are expendable in my eyes. Get rid of those and use that to reinforce the two areas we are lacking, after yesterday it looks even more obvious if it didn't already. We need a 'star' attacking player, all the teams in the league have someone. We also need a GK who has the ability to keep us in games when we're having tough moments. Get those two positions sorted and I think we're a mid-table side. Might be a bit premature, but had we had those two elements yesterday we'd have won that game 2 or 3.

He frustrates me to be honest. He's got the ability to beat a man, but his end product is so often lacking. We will need him to hit some numbers this year, it's his 2nd season of regular pro football so time is still on his side, but I'd have hoped by now we'd start seeing some end product from him - but he's still exactly the same as he was 2 years ago in my eyes. Jurys out, may never quite make the grade at the top level because of that.

Fernandes is your pretty typical number 8 style player. If you think last season we had Stu Armstrong and Rothwell who could play that role. This season we have lost both of those and gained Charly, so there is a gap for another 8 in my opinion. I wouldn't prioritise it over GK though, but maybe the club aren't - best to judge that one at the end of the window. In isolation it's a position we've lost numbers in. The only way O'Riley still comes in is if Charly goes as we need a big sale for that to happen, so we'll see how that pans out in the coming weeks. Striker wise we're probably waiting to see what happens with Sekou and Onuanchu - if we lose both of those, we almost certainly need an alternative up there as it wouldn't leave us with any natural number 9's as such (I discount Stewart, he's irrelevant as far as I'm concerned)

I like him, a really technical player, got a lot of grit to him as well. A very, very good pickup by us for the price. The cheap gems are still out there...!

I don't know why he's all of a sudden become good enough. He really isn't. I'm sure he'll be sold for £7mish in the next week or two.

I thought we played better with 11 v 11 to be honest, it was quite a bit of huff and puff by us after that point. I did see a lot of the predictions on here prior to the match, 4-0, 5-0, 3-0 etc but it was never going to be like that. First games of the season rarely play out easily and Newcastle will know for sure they've been in a game. Lots of positives in respects of how we controlled passages of the game, but ultimately a game is decided in the two boxes and that's where we came up short. I find the Alex McCarthy situation totally perplexing, this was a guy that the club deemed not good enough to be 2nd choice in the Champ - yet now they believe he is good enough to be first choice in the prem. I know it won't stay like that though, it simply can't otherwise promotion is a waste of everyone's time. As well as giving the ball away, I thought his attempt to save from Jolienton was horrific - a normal PL level keeper gets a hand on that. One thing I'll take away is our shit-housery, I quite like reading fans moaning about our foul play/games/antics - for so many years in the PL we were an absolute meek as shit soft touch, rolling over and getting our bellies tickled - if we're now going to be a bit shithouse then I'm all for it. The dark arts are important and it makes up for your limitations in other areas. Lots to build on, but the ultimate issue boiled down to exactly what every single fan has said all pre-season - the GK is not good enough. It's just blowing my mind why he's here.

He was at PNE when he was 20, not Boro. Boro was his second loan the following January.

Bednarek and Smallbone as well, but like you say with the big caveat that it's at the level below we were using them in before.

We're down Fraser as well. Could certainly see another wide player.

He's nowhere near that, only about 5'8,5'9. He's your nippy run in behind forward.

Supposedly this deal for the Chelsea guy will allow us to loan out Shea for the season to aid his development. Celtic are big fans of Shea and have enquired about him. We want O'Riley, 2+2=5 probably, but there's something to be done there - maybe.

I honestly don't think you can count Stewart as an option in any scenario. It's best that he is just discounted and we plan around him in my opinion. He hasn't had a pre-season in 2 years, still no nearer getting any game time, specialists from outside are in to try and help - it's all very damming for his future.