Ive seen McCarthy make some match winning saves, so much so he was player of the season one time.
I cant recall which game it was now as was a few seasons back but we were winning in a season where we were struggling against relegation when he made an incredible save a pushed the ball over the bar.
I understand that he is poor with his feet but call me old fashioned but I like a keeper to save the ball.
He IMO was harshly treated by the football academics on here, but I suggest most of his critics could not save anything in a Post Office account let alone on a football pitch.
Time will tell but I feel Macca is an upgrade on saving the ball, obviously not at passing it out.