Sir Ralph

Will he want to go back though. Lukaku, Havertz, Werner and Abraham are already there

Tella and Broja looking good

McCarthy has lost us points this year. Forster hasn’t made an error and looked more commanding. Decision should be clear, as well as dropping Walcott forever. Need to get a good quality attacking midfielder in Jan. albeit doubt we have money

Assume he thought El Ghazi shouldn’t have been sent off twice

Well done Ralph. Good first half and nullified them in 2nd half with bringing Lyanco on. Last season he wouldn’t have done that

Team battled really well. Lyanco was a beast at the back. Ralph sets our teams out well but we need some punch up top - if we had some money to spend on 2-3 decent attackers we’d be half decent. Walcott should not be allowed near a football pitch. His contribution so far this year is a penalty miss.

Livramento and Broja both looked excellent. Not convinced by Perraud - KWP deserves to be playing particularly after Chelsea. I would be more effective than Walcott if I was blind folded and sent onto the pitch. Thank goodness Armstrong is back.

Great performance- robbed by that twat Moss

Absolutely robbed. So Walker won the challenge legally?

Useless ref

Seriously xxx off redmond you waste of space. Mentally weak everytime

Yes pretty good window overall - best for a while: Positives; Good money for Ings and reasonable for Jannik Got rid of Lemina, Gunn and Hoedt Armstrong looks like a decent striker for reasonable money Tino looks a steal We now have at least 2 players for each position - v important Negatives Could maybe have got a new keeper and got rid of Forster / McCarthy Would have been good to have a Romeu replacement We signed Walcott

Agree like his attitude

If he’s as good as people say he is I hope we are ready to offer him a new contract when he turns 18! This has been a pretty good transfer window to be fair to those in charge. We have lost Ings and Vestegaard and I’m still saying that so they must be doing something right. I get the feeling that this is the first year and Ralph and Seemens are less hamstrung by the unsellables and they are starting to show what they can do

Is three years the maximum a 17 year old can sign?

Seems like this guy is intended to be back up. That’s fine as long as we use our surplus funds for a LB and defensive midfielder. If Perraud or Romeu get injured we are in trouble. I think a lot of the problems we had last year was missing the holding player and physicality that Romeu has and we need to be able to replace that when he isn’t playing.

Kid is great. Reminds me of SHAW at same age.

Agree he is underrated- when did he last make an error that cost us? He’s only got one year left too

Really good performance- better team against one of the the potential title contenders (albeit an outside one). Romeu, JWP, Stephens, Adams and Tino all good. Walcott was gash. maybe Ralph had clicked by changing things at half term.

I had an email from the club confirming you can share a ticket when I asked the question. Think they would struggle to prosecute after that!

maybe but still no excuse. There is a QR code option which also doesnt appear to work

Ticket office manager should be fired. Completely incompetent.

My initial reaction was Phillips would be a bad move. However, read this on the Liverpool Fans Forum - maybe we are underestimating him. https://forums.liverpoolfc.com/threads/404968-Nat-Phillips/page42 £15m would be too much

If we finalise this, the window is starting to shape up for us. Sell Vestegaard, get replacement CB, back up LB and CM (the Ox). if we achieved this it would be the first season that Ralph mainly has players that he wants in his team which gives me more optimism. To date he has been working with a group of players, most of whom are not his aquistion.

If Armstrong is our No1 target, this is pretty poor bearing in mind we have £28m for Ings. Need to pull something pretty special out of the bag if we are going to lose out on Armstrong over a couple of mill.