What experience has Carrick got over Rogers?
I think this is half the problem with our fanbase, many seem to have these really snobby views about who fits the profile to be a Saints manager. It's obvious that we would benefit from a standard no nonsense, experienced Championship manager, yet far too many of our fans want hipster managers who look great in a pair of chinos and white trainers, but insist on playing tippy tappy shitball against Championship sloggers.
We need to drop the snobbery, accept that we're in a real mess and bring someone in who's going to kick the players arses and not accept any bullshit.