Agree its a bit harsh, especially because five posts up DPS says Clyne now looks "excellent". Which is it?
FWIW I think he is a very good 1v1 defender. I can't think of any goals he has been at fault for aside from when he slipped versus Man Utd. Teams will look to exploit his size so its up to him to find a way to deal with that.
Excellent partnership with Puncheon.