Roger

Don't want him out but after the last few years are we now saying he's only a disaster if we are notion 4? We are happy to regress to 23th or 13th are we?

Instead of Williams or ball? Not in same class.

Victor for me.

Shilton Clyne Wright vvd Dennis Ball Williams Le tissier channon Paine Keegan Subs Niemi, Davies, Toby, Armstrong, mane, bridge, Moran Morgan nowhere near

Completely concur. No way he'd get in all time team. Williams was much better. Could go past players and create things. For me Santana is a better player.

Proven. He's never scored many goals and has scored 0 in 21!

Proven. He's never scored many goals and has scored 0 in 21!

Team will be: Forster Cedric fonte vvd Bertrand Romeo hoojberg Davis Redmond j rod boufal I'd rather tadic for Redmond but will see.

I'd sell him. He's gone 0 goals in 21 and yet people talking about him Like he's a world beater. We need strikers yes, but not one that doesn't score. Granted he played well end of last season, but that was very much the exception to the rule with him looking at his goal scoring record.

Well imo a fit j rod is a different class to long.

J rod before injury scored goals and was class. Long had half a good season.

Why long he's not anywhere near good enough. Don't understand supporters obsession with someone who doesn't score goals.

So pleased for j rod. Clasie was very good and Bertrand

Nothing to do with him being mates with puel!

No way yoshida been as good. Fonte has been fab recently.

They aren't in same class.

The manager is rubbish.

Wtf? Asylum beckons mate.

0 goals in 19 games. Long should sought himself out.

Fernandes was in a different league to Redmond.

Anyone heard anything about takeover?

He was awful. The replacements for mane look poor so far.

That's looking at things how you want to. Fonte has proved very loyal over the years and that might not be the case. The sheer amount of players who have left over last few years I think suggests that the club aren't whiter than white.

Surely this is one player who the club should reach out to. He's been outstanding for club and plus very difficult to replace. If we undertake our defence with our current forward line there's a fine line between mid table and relegation battle.

How long do you judge form on? As he was awful for Norwich last season and my brum mate says he was poor for them.