Select on merit only! I agree. Which is exactly why the club are encouraging particular groups of people to apply (and I agree they could do more for other groups beyond the ones they mentioned). They want the best. If the club see that applicants for positions are not representative of the local community, then they need to find a way to encourage under-represented groups to apply, otherwise they most likely won't be getting the best candidates (unless, of course, you think that some types of people are intrinsically better than others).