Saint_clark

What's this Semmens' background then? Never heard his name mentioned before, has he been at the club in a different role or is he completely new? Sent from my Pixel 3 using Tapatalk

The way they've acted in this match will be totally ignored by the "women's football is so much fairer" brigade who champion it as a bastion of sportsmanship and fair play. Sent from my Pixel 3 using Tapatalk

If he was so good we would be willing to pay more than £14million. Seems even saints know they're aiming low with this transfer. Sent from my Pixel 3 using Tapatalk

Ok, now I have. Done. Sent from my Pixel 3 using Tapatalk

I haven't. Sent from my Pixel 3 using Tapatalk

Austins goal highlights featured much better worked goals than the one above. I don't know why people are so upset that i'm not excited by a signing. I'm excited by Djenepo if that helps.

I viewed Hasenhuttls preference to be creating chances quickly after winning the ball back high up the pitch, in which case someone able to cross from deep would be a real asset.

That was what I said originally. As Adrian said above, unlikely to get the space/amount of chances he got in the Championship...defenders will be more alert, quicker to close down and sharper in the tackle and keepers won't be as slow to react. If he gets double figures I will happily hold my hands up and say I was wrong, but I just haven't seen anything about him to be able to get excited.

This coupled with the fact that most of his goals required very little skill on his part is what makes me think this signing is a mistake. People go on about his pace but I don't even see any evidence of that, doesn't seem to be any quicker than Austin.

Whilst I agree with the idea of having experience in key positions, one positive I take from Ralph's under 24s only rule is that it seems as if he's planning on being here for 3-4 years to grow a team himself. Sent from my Pixel 3 using Tapatalk

I think both Begovic and Boruc are better than Hart too...not sure why Bournemouth are interested in the same way I wasn't sure why Burnley wanted him when they had Heaton and that other lad whose name escapes me.

He must have something about him to have had a successful career but it's a fact that since he's been at the club every keeper we've had has regressed or stagnated, time for some new coaching techniques me thinks.

£20million please.

Ings finishing is very good but he will be injured for half the season. Long showed signs of improvement after working with Hasenhuttl...I think he could have his best season yet for us.

How can Chuka Umuna not hold a by-election now that he's not only left the Labour party to set up a new party, but joined the Lib Dems - the party that got just over 3000 votes in his constituency in the last election at 6.5% of the vote? Personally think the law needs to change so that anyone who leaves/joins a party whilst being an elected MP automatically triggers a by-election.

Was just thinking this, will be a lot of resentment from the players dropped out of the side.

I wouldn't imagine Obafemi would be kicking up a fuss already, at 18 years old, about not being in line for a chunk of games next season. A loan out to a league one side would be best I think - not that I think that's his level, but you want him to get experience and learn the game without damaging his confidence in his abilities.

Interesting to see how differently people interpret the fixtures, that looks a horrific start to me. Away to "lesser" sides who are tough to beat or riding high, home to one of the best sides in the world and then United who are always tough, away to Spurs, home to the team that are desperate to beat us at St Marys...someone said we could be top 4 by the end of september, I think it's more likely we'll be rock bottom!

Agreed, say we sell him for £15million, we're basically saying that having him for two years is worth less than that. Having said that I seem to have more faith in Targett than most. I won't be too worried either way but if we do sell Bertrand i'd hope that we'd push for £20million.

Wasn't jumping on anyone buddy, just pointing out that high spending is common place now and not an indicator of anything really.

Indeed, his shots to scuff ratio is a worry.

Fulham spent more than that on a striker and never looked like staying up. Sent from my Pixel 3 using Tapatalk

An exciting signing. Not expecting huge things for this season as its a huge step up, but over the next 3 or 4 years could be a big player for us. Takes the pressure off Redmond slightly too. Sent from my Pixel 3 using Tapatalk

Honestly don't see much difference between Gallagher and Adams, and Sims is a different player but yes i'd rather have him. Sims has been dangerous every time he's played and the majority of that has been in a limited and underperforming defensive side.

As I said, not writing him off and will support him. Just can't get excited over this signing from the evidence available.