Matthew Le God

Can you really not see how any player or staff member would likely view a move to RB Leipzig as preferable to the Championship? When did I say we should be grateful about it?

Your question in the stadium was this... "so when’s the stadium expansion likely to happen then? Any timescales yet?" I have never claimed to know more about it than anything that isn't already in the press. The council, club, owner/chairman and CEO have all been talking about it in the last 18 months. Name a single strawman fallacy I've used.

Well if that was the choice, the Göztepe manager is doing the best job of the three SR managers so far. That doesn't mean he'd be right for us though.

🙄 They can't be answered due to the very nature of them being strawman fallacies! You've misrepresented my position and then asked questions based on that misrepresentation. It is fundamentally flawed.

How is it a reason when the club do not make the game? The rest of your post is riddled with strawman fallacies.

What question have I avoided? On numerous occasions I have listed benefits of a multi club model. I even listed some in this thread in the last hour. Now answer my question please.

1) You avoided the question. 2) I have criticised Sport Republic numerous times. 3) "All to keep the gig of being the official saints FM researcher? Dont worry, I’m sure the club will be happy at your input here so will renew your contract for another year." Utterly bizarre! The club do not make FM or give me a contract! 4) Yes, there has been a number of stadium expansion pieces of news from the council, club, Solak and Parsons in the past 18 months.

What did I say in that post that is not true?

Why would he agree to being loaned to the Championship when he had an offer from RB Leipzig? They can't force him against his will.

They can't force him to sign for a 2nd tier English club if he also had an option to join a big club in Germany on bigger wages. Numerous benefits to the multi club model. We've seen some small ones already. With player movement and player loan development. It isn't a short term thing, the big benefits will take time and if you never start them you'll never see them. Some fans are short termist, especially when they see the lub struggling. That does not mean long term plans should all be axed.

If it formed part of the money for Jander or Scienza would you be questioning it?

True, but I've never said otherwise.

Why would he join Championship Saints over RB Leipzig?

You asked a question. I answered it. You complain your question was answered.

Sold for a profit = benefit for Saints

Why would he agree to join Saints in the Championship rather than RB Leipzig?

The player that signed for one of the best teams in Germany in the summer.

How is signing a very promising player like Kayi Sanda not a benefit Saints? How is selling a player like Juan to Göztepe for a profit, not a benefit for Saints?

You avoided the question

Which 1st team regular players we have made a profit on do you think we should have kept? The only good ones we've had have gone to elite clubs and/or extremely rich and/or in a higher league and it is unrealistic to think they'd stay.

As I said yesterday, I have criticised them on their shit show of recruitment on numerous occasions.

Which players are you suggesting they should have kept?

I've done that numerous times on this forum. I've stated they have made some huge fuck ups in terms of recruitment, which has left us in a mess. Despite that, their heart appears in the right place and their money is going into the club, not out of it. So it isn't as bad as it could be with numerous other owners in world football.

What aspect of being in a multi club group did that?

Why not?