Matthew Le God

Do you know what his exact tasks were under Martin and Juric? Plus he wasn't making final decisions at that time.

Yep, based on what? Out of your depth in the PL does not mean the players aren't good enough for a promotion challenge in the Championship.

Even if they were still in the Championship they could not get remotely close to his wages, let alone in League 1. Stephens is currently on PL level wages probably north of £60k per week. Even with a 40% relegation paycut, non parachute payments Championship teams could not afford him, let alone Plymouth in League 1. He'd really need to want the move for it to happen, as it'll be a monumental wage cut!

Based on what? The issue is recruitment. We have a new recruitment team that have not had a transfer window yet to judge them on.

The younger players haven't really been been the main issue. It is the older ones we've signed that are not good enough!

They have made steps to do that. But we can't see any possible rewards of that until the transfer window opens.

Cash

Strawman fallacy! That was him as a manager. We were discussing his impact as a coach under Martin and then Juric.

Very hard to judge a coaches impact when you don't know what coaching tasks he was assigned. Plus he wasn't ultimately responsible making tactical decisions, when he was just coaching that was on Martin and Juric.

Very harsh to judge the new recruitment team on the mistakes of the old recruitment team.

Pre his caretaker/interim manager roles how do you know what his coaching did didn't do?

What do we really know about his ability to coach rather than manage?

Mission accomplished! Although to be fair, the club was already on the decline when SR had their takeover.

I don’t think there ever was a good case for that! Being part of the coaching setup perhaps, but not being at the top and in charge!

Which players do you think are League 1 or below level? I don't think any of the first team are, bar perhaps Lumley. Very few of them are PL level (KWP, Ramsdale, Dibling, Fernandes), most of the others are top half Championship level players. Certainly not League 1 or lower.

Extremely harsh to judge people on the actions of those that came before them. It is rational to withold judgement until you see how they do.

Only seem to need to explain them to you. Perhaps others haven't had a humour bypass!

Walker-Peters, Fernandes, Dibling & Ramsdale.

None of those 2 or 3 years had the current recruitment team at the club. So that experience is irrelevant.

We are allowed to sign new ones.

Why not?

Because it was a joke, hence the emoji.

We are allowed to sign new players.