S-Clarke

I think that was one of Ralf Kruger's 5 pledges. They found it down the back of the desk.

Alex McCarthy - 9 Baz - 9 KWP - 6 - His effort has been a little down this year, some games it looks like he's going through the motions. AMN - 1 - Gives the impression that he'd rather be anywhere else than a football pitch. Lyanco - 9 - You certainly cannot fault this guys commitment. DCC - 4 - Not sure he's been great, I think he's been causing a few ripples behind the scenes as well. Arribo -100 - Shocking attitude, it's like he expects his ability to do all the work for him and he doesn't really want to lift a finger. Might get you buy in the SPL, but it won't in any proper leagues. JWP - 9 - One thing you can't fault is his effort and commitment, pretty much an ever present for years. Never misses a game. Always one of the highest runners in any game we play. AA - 1 - I don't think he wants to be here, plays like he doesn't give a shit. Che - 8 - The guy always puts in a shift, one of the few I'd be happy to stay. Orsic - n/a - not sure how you can rate him, not seen him. Tall Paul - n/a - not sure he's really done enough to be rated yet either. James Bree -n/a - can't rate him, just hasn't played. Romain Peraud - 9 - One of the best things about this guy is his effort, a niggly little bastard. Stu - 6 - As per KWP, dropped from previous seasons. Doesn't have the same energy to get around the pitch. Mara - n/a - A young kid, harsh to judge. Plays like he doesn't 'get it' yet, too early to give up. Moussa - 7 - Can't fault the guys effort. Sulemana - n/a - not seen enough of him really. Sillysue - 4 - His commitment has always been a bit iffy to me, seems to be more focused on his next move than playing for us. Edozie - n/a - young kid, can't really mark him. Similar as mara really. Elyounoussi - 5 - He tries, can't really deny that. Charly - 9 - Love the guys attitude, commitment and effort. Always buzzing around, a real nightmare to mark. Diallo - 5 - I don't think you can say he doesn't put in an effort, he's just not good enough. Theo- 7 - Puts in the shift within the limited parameters he can perform in. He shouldn't really be playing top level football, but it's not his fault he's being picked. Still does his best. Janny B - 0 - This guy is the worst for me. I cannot just take notice of the last 6 months and ignore what went on previous. ''Happy to move to a bigger club'' in the summer, and then, as Ralph put it, he was more focused on Poland last season than the club who pays his wages. Get rid. Ketchup - 5 - Not amazing commitment shown yet, but he's young. Got a lot to learn. He seems a bit of a bailer though. Lavia - 10 - Cannot question this guy, works his arse off. He has the attitude to back up the ability. He will go to the top, notwithstanding a major injury.

And in the process of doing so have probably ruined what could have been a decent career for Gavin. It'll take a lot for him to come back from this season, be interesting if the club stick or discard him.

The experienced signings have been poor, but if you look at our scouting setup (and equally when Shields was with us), their expertise was youth...so you'd kind of expect them to have better results from young players rather than 'pro's'. We need more balance in the recruitment department, as like you say it's all well and good looking to the future but we also need to think about 'now' - and we didn't, hence why we were relegated. Aribo, DCC, Bree, Orsic, Onuachu. AMN. But that's not just exclusive to this year either, look at last summer - Theo, Lyanco, Armstrong. The season before that...Diallo, Minamino etc. All the proven players we sign are either incapable of playing in this league or washed up. This goes back quite some time, so I'm in support of what SR are trying to do in terms of ripping up our scouting dept - it hasn't been right for years and needs a reset.

It's true and definitely the other part of the argument which needs to be heard. It's easy to call out the scouting as being 'crap' for every single instance, but it hasn't. They've picked up ABK, Lavia, Alcaraz - and I've always felt it's too soon to judge Mara, Edozie, Larios etc. Using an example of recruitment in the u18's, we scouted and picked up Sam Amo-Ameyaw who has the potential to be a bit of a player. It's not all as bad as has been made out, for an Orsic there is an Alcaraz.

Not as good as Che's statement, this one feels much more PR/generic.

Which is all well and good, but they didn't replace his experience. It left a void and they called that wrong. I doubt Girona's interest came up in the final 24 hrs, it would have been there in the background for a few weeks, so we had plenty of time to sort out a replacement for him - but we were nieve and thought JWP, Lavia and Diallo were enough. They weren't.

I don't think the Captain is at the club, I think this is the summer we recruit a new captain who can come in and shake it up a bit. Vice Captain, again...no idea. Lack of leadership throughout the side, so it's hard to pin that on anyone. Maybe Stephens if he comes back? Set Piece taker will almost certainly be Smallbone, he's got a very similar technique to JWP and delivers great crosses from the inside right in open play as well.

Fairly sure it comes to the Championship in season 24/25, so we won't be away from it for too long.

Don't underestimate the battle for 11th, quite a few teams ready to catch Chelsea to claim those honours.

I assume these are two of the people who clapped. Jenny watched the Saints game on Saturday with her friend: She said: “The players gave their all so what else can they do? “We’ve followed Saints through all the way from Division One and we will renew our season tickets.” In what way can any sane football fan look at yesterdays game, ignoring the season as a whole, and proclaim they gave their all? I mean, seriously? what are these people watching? wake the fuck up.

Yep ditto, I think a lot of this feeling is because of the fact it's been a slow inevitable death - we've kind of all known for months, it's not crept up on us like a last min shock so i think a lot of us have been able to prepare our minds. The last time we were relegated we put up more of an effort and took it to the last game, so a lot of us still had a hope we'd make it. This season I think we all knew we'd never, ever take this to the final few games.

There are a small handful of good eggs at the club, people I'd be happy to keep around, and Che is certainly one of them. I still think a club will come in though, even one of the Promoted teams will see what he can bring to a team. (Burnley's Ashley Barnes replacement, maybe) At least he's said sorry though, first apology we've had from anyone connected to the club. One of the only few who has shown they give a shit.

Pretty scathing view from Le Tiss "I’ve never witnessed such a gutless, lazy and passionless performance from a relegation-threatened team in all my life, that squad should hang their heads in shame.”

Martin isn't that highly thought of by Swansea fans believe it or not, they only had an uptick towards the end of the season. A lot of their fans wanted him out before they woke up at the end of the season when there was nothing to play for. Not totally convinced, I still think he's unproven and hasn't pulled up any trees in the Championship. I'd look at the likes of Mark Robbins or Carrick before him if we were looking at existing Champ managers.

My issue with JWP's statement, outside the generic media coached nature of it, was the acceptance that standards dropped, we haven't done it right since the first day of pre-season etc. Well James, you're the captain, why the fuck have you not be tearing shit up to raise those standards? As club captain he sets the standards for others to follow, if they're not following those then he needs to call them out. But he won't as he's too meek, he sums up our entire team and fan base. I can't criticise him for the effort he's given us over the years, the free kicks and such, but as a leader - in my opinion - he has been our worst ever PL captain and has been captain of our WORST ever team (going by defeats in a league season). I don't have much time for him saying standards dropped after the event, where the fuck was he in September and October? Where the fuck was he galvanising the group when we were 3-1 up against Arsenal on 88 mins? Where was he against Wolves when we were 1-0 up, against 10 min, on 77 mins? Where was he when we lost 9-0 - not once, but twice. And where the fuck was he yesterday?

You're being a bit of a bore here. It's quite clear what everyone means by experience, it has been spelt out to you and on previous posts, so stop trying to be clever as you're tripping yourself up.

Might soften the immediate blow, but if I'm honest we could do without two clubs like that coming down with us. They'll both be extra competitive and will have money, it'll make next season more difficult. I think one of those two will go, but still hoping the other is Forest.

You missed out the diseased pitch.

If we see a substational change in playing staff then yeah, I'll be back in the Champ - don't have a ST this year, so it won't be a renew. However I will refuse to pay a penny if we are forced to watch Diallo, Bednarek, Lynaco, A Armstrong and co stink out the Championship.

I look at it similar to the Koeman season, that could have been a really, really messy season had we had an inexperienced/young manager overseeing that level of change. But we had someone with the reputation and presence of Koeman to steady everyone, and demand instant respect and high standards. We recruited well, but I think having someone of his ilk drove standards massively. An inexperienced young coach, no matter how much potential they have, will not do that - and in a summer where we will go through substantial change, we need a figure head who knows football at the top of it all.

A complete nonsense statement really.

I don't think we're naive enough to think he has no influence, maybe not full influence, but his fingers are still all over this no matter what anyone says.

Yeah I'd put Alcaraz, Lavia, KWP in that 90% cohort - but the rest are a bunch of wankers, and I include JWP in that after his 'efforts' today. I cannot accept that.

And who lead that? JWP. Good loyal guy and all that, but he is a key component of the leaderless mess we've seen this year. (And since he's been captain tbf).