hypochondriac

Surely he will play LM Saturday with Harding behind him?

You talk a lot of sense John B.

I think Stu would be the first to admit he is sometimes too oppinionated for his own good. He makes bold predictions which sometimes blow up in his face and make him look foolish. He does however make a lot of valid points (even if he does put some of them accross too forcefully on ocassion.) I think if everyone (including Stu) followed the rule of the previous incarnation of the forum: "play the ball not the man" then things would be a lot better and posters may concede that many of Stu's concerns are legitimate.

Only Stu claimed that as far as I could see. I commented a couple of times on the speculation that the Echo had been banned.

I agree with you, I don't think someone should make a statement saying they had been banned when no one was sure either way. It should have been speculation. Well done to Steve who got the definitive answer. Unfortunatel, where SFC is concerned it is often difficult to get these answers and so speculation will continue.

Although the first post does say "seems". Someone found out the truth and the thread was locked. Looked like the forum was working well.

Lol. I genuinely think you need some help (if you are being serious that is.)

Do give it a rest you tiresome individual.

All about opinions I suppose. I just know the football I watched was of a better quality last season than the season before. That's from both teams.

Clearly I wasn't talking about isolated games, I was talking about the season in general. Forest at home 2 seasons ago would be a perfect point to explain how awful championship football can be if I were going down that route.

Pretty sure his style was. Extreme yes but I get the point.

IMO the quality of football last season was of a higher quality than most of the football I saw in the CCC.

What personal abuse? Mostly I see people seriously questioning his approach.

Thanks to the other quieter posters who feel a similar way to how I do. Nice to hear from you as well MB. I hope you post a bit more again. As an old timer like myself, believe me when I say you are missed!

I agree Duncan. Constantly referring to your BA job is out of order, especially considering the problems you have had in the past few months. Whatever, keep passing on your views to people you know will appreciate it. Perhaps you will have to confine yourself to communications via PM in future. I know that is something I am considering. Perhaps time for me to have a break from posting.

well said

Do you still believe that the opinion of someone who did not go to the game is more valid than the opinion of someone who went?

hallelujah!

Care to comment on the Echo being banned?

So who do you define as a problem member then? I disagree with a lot of people but I wouldn't request that they have less posts than myself purely because I hold a different opinion to them. TDD maybe because he is a troll (and admits it.)

Yep pretty much agree with that. There are quite a few positives but also a fair few negatives. I just want the negative aspects addressing (mostly the communication with the fans) and I'll be dead happy.

It really has. I think the main difference is how much bigger and more strictly moderated this is compared to the early days of saintsforever.

Precisely! I now have to attempt to go to the fans forum so I can seek out answers when really I shouldn't have to, these questions should have been answered on the OS when the decisions were taken and although I would still be unhappy, I would accept it.

I think there are a minority on both sides who ruin the discussion for everyone else because they polarise everything and put forward ridiculous arguments both for and against Cortese.

So they've cancelled it. Release a statement and let fans know. What you don't do is just get rid and not say anything about it.