I have never once said he isn't entitled to his view. I personally put more weight behind the opinions of someone who watches a player week in week out compared to someone who never goes. If I never attended the saints games, I believe that someone' criticisms of a player are more valid than mine if I did.
Do you not agree that your opinions on a player will be much less informed than someone who watches a player every week? If have listened to quite a few Aston Villa games this year and I have an opinion on a few of their players but I would place much more value on a Villa season ticket holder's opinion of their players than mine. Not sure why this is such a contentious issue, it seems perfectly obvious to me.