hypochondriac

Eh? Of course you are entitled to think it was a nazi salute, just as I am entitled to think you're wrong. The discussion continued because we've had a number of statements about that difference of opinion including that I'm far right, a far right apologist, that anyone who thinks it isn't a nazi salute is cowed by Musk's wealth, that believing it's not a nazi salute in some way disrespects Jews who died in the holocaust and that the ADL are compromised because they've been neutered by Trump.

I see that the government is now blaming Amazon and the knife for the Southport attack. Personally I think we should just ban taxis then he never woukd have been able to get to the little girl's dance class.

I've got my laughing emoji primed and ready.

My point is that it isn't a settled issue like some are claiming. Equally because some people agree with you it doesn't make them or you correct. There's no comparison between what Musk did and Corbyn laying a wreath because there's no dispute that he actually did it.

Hardly the worst crime in the world.

It's disputed by an awful lot of credible people including organisations such as the ADL. Many individuals do not consider it clear, not least because of the words he used immediately after doing it and the fact he is laughing at the idea that it was viewed as one.

Or maybe when you say my heart goes out to you and you pat your heart and gesture up to the crowd. Musk has denied it was a nazi salute, no one here is making a claim that he's a Nazi so there seems little reason for him to do one and then deny it.

Is there any context where eit is possible to do a similar gesture and it not be construed as a Nazi salute?

Possible motive was that he was a racist and hated white English people:

It was ridiculous to have a go at Corbyn for not bowing enough if that's what someone was criticising him for. This account of Musk definitely doing a Nazi salute is disputed. There's no dispute that Corbyn placed a wreath.

I know they're clear to you but you're posting history makes it clear that your judgement is irredemably flawed.

Sorry I don't understand the comparison.

The main trait of being a Nazi is being proudly and up front about supporting Jews.

So anyone who disputes the claim that Musk was doing a nazi salute are cowed by Musk's money? What a claim! You know those Jews though, they're happy to parrot any old belief for a bit of money.

I'll continue to bat your soft balls away all day and laugh when you make unevidenced claims about me that are untrue.

A rampant zionist who is far right and defends Nazis. Make it make sense!

Likewise. Always happy for you not to respond.

I don't need lectures from anyone about the horrors of the Holocaust, the discrimination my Jewish friends still experience or how awful places in Poland are that I've visited a few times. I've been accuse of being a rampant zionist on here and am a staunch supporter of the Jewish people. None of that has any relevance whatsoever to this issue and I can find just as many authoritative sources - including Jewish people - who are laughing at what you're saying.

We can all post numerous links with opposing opinions. Bit pointless though.

Thanks but I'll post when I want and don't need your permission xxx

Hopefully you're not talking about me. I haven't admired anyone, I don't really care much about Musk I'm just challenging the idea that he's a Nazi.

Yes you're right right it's a Nazi salute. So Musk is a Nazi yes?

The ADL have said it wasn't a Nazi salute. HTH.

Elon Musk secret nazi confirmed!!

It was mostly to do with foreigners coming here and doing stuff to English children-specifically girls. That's what caused everything to kick off as well as the nice weather of course. Wouldn't catch people out in January.