Jump to content

hypochondriac

Subscribed Users
  • Posts

    46,280
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by hypochondriac

  1. Indeed. Not sure why the club would know much at this point.
  2. Reading the caveats in the reporting, the "up to six months" ban is pote tally good news. That means that six months is potentially the absolute upper limit for a ban. Maybe this is before mitigation, legal argument from our side about proportionality etc.
  3. Who are all these sources chatting shit to everyone. If they're going to ban him then just fucking do it now don't leave everyone hanging on for another week.
  4. I don't think our lawyers will view it that way if we have to go down the legal route.
  5. I can absolutely see the logic in him getting charged. My only quarrel is with the perceived double standard between the warning for Bielsa and the charge for Tonda when on the face of it the Bielsa FA rule breach is more egregious.
  6. But you could argue that it's the club's decision to continue to employ him. Sack him and it's problem solved for the club...
  7. Presumably the answer would be that the FA have deemed it to have broken their rules because we've broken our league rules but that's not a way to run things. The FA could potentially disagree with the rules of the EFL.
  8. Indeed. Not difficult to understand and one of the things I'd expect the lawyers to be asking if we don't get a result we deem to be fair.
  9. Who is they in that scenario? Your post is an explanation for why the EFL treated us differently, not why the FA would treat Tonda differently for breaking the same rule as Bielsa (arguably to a lesser extent since Tonda only did it three times.)
  10. Technically it was just three instances of the same thing (that we had already admitted to months ago.) Not sure why it's such big news.
  11. You're the one who is misunderstanding. There is no spying rule in the FA rulebook. He broke the EFL rules and that's why the club was charged by the EFL. There is no different rule to break under fa rules that has changed since beilsa broke the rule previously.
  12. Bored of their antics. He was always worth close to 30.
  13. Some suggestion that the reason for the delay was due to Tpndas's pregnant wife. If so then fair enough?
  14. Of course you look at precedent when deciding on punishments. Bielsa clearly broke the exact same rule that Tonda has done but got nothing more than a warning whilst Tonda has been charged.
  15. OK so why three charges for Tonda and none for Bielsa who seemingly did it even more? Surely he broke the same FA rule?
  16. Whilst t I agree with you , I think the point with the FA is that they haven tgot a new rule and so I struggle to see why Bielsa wasn't charged by them as seemingly the rules haven't changes for their organisation since his case.
  17. I assume they know we aren't likely to contest the charges so hsould have the punishment announced for next Tuesday.
  18. I believe that the point of the lawyer in the tweet above.
  19. Interesting tweet
  20. Presumably three separate charges isn't good but there will also be some sort of mitigation (a clean record beforehand, admitted it and fully cooperated with them).
  21. Chatgpt knows fuck all really.
  22. We have but Tonda hasn't personally for his role in it.
  23. Presumably someone at the club was under the impression that it was being announced this morning.
  24. I think that the punishment I predicted would be wildly inappropriate but I thought that about kicking us out of the playoffs too.
  25. Anyone want to stick their neck out and predict punishment? I'm going with substantial fine and ban from all football related activities for three months. Reduced to two on appeal.
×
×
  • Create New...