CanadaSaint

Foy makes me want to vomit. Rose's handball inside the box was far more blatant than the penalty he gave against Fox ar Newcastle. In all the years I've been watching football, the current crop of crap is the direst collection of officials I've ever seen.

Not one of his biggest fans - yet, but I thought Gaston played very well today. I probably wouldn't have started him, preferring to get Puncheon in and reinstate the Clyne/Punch partnership, but I was rather disappointed when he went off - even if Davis solidified things for us at a key time. I just took a lengthy run through RAWK and several of them made admiring comments about three of our players - Schneiderlin, Lallana and Shaw. When it comes to value, there aren't many around who can bring to the table what Schneiderlin brings, game-in and game-out. And now he's consistently adding goals to his resume, he's moving towards elite player status.

I'm not writing him off at all. He has tremendous skill and a vision that's often far ahead of those around him, but I have three concerns. He's not proven himself tough enough for the weekly grind of the Premier League, and we can't afford midfield time-outs at this level. His set-piece delivery has, so far, been poor. And - this perhaps above all - I'm not sure that he fits very well into Pochettino's high-pressing style; when he goes into one of his low-profile phases, it adds a lot to Schneiderlin's and Cork's already-heavy workload. It could be a case of Ramirez OR Lallana but not Ramirez AND Lallana.

I spend quite a bit of time reading other teams' forums, and I've never seen the kind of everyday nasty junk that - by virtue of just a few posters - contaminates this one.

100% correct. Him and his pitiful little band of sneerers. Ironic that two of the worst appear in the first four posts. Yet again, a few p.o.s. screw it up for the many.

I think Nigel has a legal duty to "mitigate his loss", which means that he needs to actively seek alternative employment and take any reasonable position offered to him. Only then would it become clear what he's lost through his (apparently) unfair dismissal. The courts are there to either make that decision or (indirectly) force parties who'd rather avoid the courts to come to an agreement. This isn't personal, as some are so keen to characterize it, but relatively normal practice in situations like this. As much as I think he handled it poorly, all this whining about Cortese is uniformed drivel from the usual suspects. As for those who hope Nigel sticks it to us on a financial and even playing level, that's just pathetic.

For me we dodged a few bullets today. For a start, I'd love to know what the deal is with Forren because I don't understand why we would opt to reunite a central defence pairing that was hung, drawn and quartered by almost everyone that played against them. And we played Maya at right back against a team that usually attacks with pace and width. And, on top of that, we didn't start Puncheon, who strengthens our right side offensively and helps with wide coverage defensively. Having said that, it's a game we should have won - and would have won IMO if Pochettino had brought Puncheon on at around the 60-minute mark. My patience and belief regarding Ramirez are evaporating rapidly. I can buy into all the "he's got tons of skill", "he's still very young", and "he's still adapting to the PL" stuff. To a point. But he's too lightweight, especially for a game and weather conditions like that, and there is no excuse - none whatsoever - for failing to beat the first defender with three successive set pieces.

That game was there for the winning. I thought Pardew and Adkins made some bizarre substitutions but this guy is on another planet.

We need Punch on the right to run at them but also provide some cover for Yoshida.

And we all know how games like this end, don't we?

I've got faith in Pochettino and his style but, for me, he's dropped two big selection clangers in successive games - not starting Puncheon at Newcastle and starting Ramirez today. I hope we quickly get back to what we were doing three weeks ago. Davis is not much more than a journeyman midfielder but he fits very well into the high press.

We will not play a high-pressing game, at least not successfully or consistently, with Ramirez in the line up. Schneiderlin - a key factor in the high aggression - has to play deeper to cover for Ramirez's style, so the press is essentially gone right there. Ramirez may have some cracking skills but he doesn't fit into the so-called Pochettino style. I'm shocked he picked him today.

As soon as I heard Ramirez was starting I knew we'd struggle because of the lost bite in the middle of the pitch. Sure he's talented but he's far too lightweight for a game like this - and probably for the Premier League. Whenever Ramirez plays we lose the marauding element of Schneiderlin's game because he has to err on the side of caution.

Apologies if already posted somewhere: http://www.teamtalk.com/southampton/8527441/Suarez-is-creator-in-chief-in-Premier-League?

Edit: I'll update and check the Strugglers League table tonight and post it tomorrow.

Very good news. However, there has been a major uptick today in the speculation regarding Luke Shaw, suggesting that we are actually talking with Chelsea, and that worries me greatly.

It is a vile and offensive post and it should have been removed long ago. No surprise that you would endorse it, though, in your pitiful playground adulation of the obnoxious element of the forum.

I don't have much time for him either but think people have been a bit hard on him today - damned by his well-deserved reputation for poor positioning and slow recovery. For me the goals were tough breaks rather than outright errors. But I won't be too surprised if he's retained at the end of the season. At this level it's risking a lot to have a 17 year-old as cover for a 17 year-old. It all depends on our budget. Worried but not surprised. The trouble with him being in the squad is that sooner or later he's going to play.

It hasn't taken you long to establish your 'credentials' on here. You might be the quickest poster to go on "ignore", and I seldom use it.

There's a difference between sh*tting himself and sh*tting himself. To be fair, Ramirez is willing to go into dangerous situations but his head goes down too easily. There's little sign of the kind of "steel" in his game that I think we'll need next week. On the bench yes, starting line up NFW.

It's a game in which intestinal fortitude will be crucial because they are fighting for their lives. And so, in truth, are we. What, exactly, has Ramirez done to suggest that we can rely on him to contribute in that kind of game? Genuine question Roger. I don't really doubt his talent. It's his balls that worry me.

The rules say that it's hand ball if a player "handles the ball deliberately (except for the goalkeeper within his own penalty area)", but it's been interpreted differently fo some time. That allows tools like Foy and Dowd the licence to be homers and to give a penalty in one case but not another. FIFA needs to get a grip on this because nobody really knows what hand ball is any more.

He might be too lightweight for the Premier League and I'm not sure he really wants to be here any more. Nor am I sure that Pochettino has a lot of faith in him. I'd be surprised if he's here at the start of next season.

For me, Pochettino made a big mistake with his starting line up by leaving Puncheon out. We really missed his pace and his interplay with Clyne, and his absence gave Newcastle the comfort to attack us down that side. In fact, I think that Pochettino was our-coached by Pardew today. He's smart enough to learn, though.

Speaking as one who wasn't that unhappy to see him go, I thought that Mr. Pardew did an excellent job today.