No, working with and analysing academy players and players aged 16-20 who represent their country is another approach. Having a run out for your first team doesn’t necessarily mean you’re a weak link just because he isn’t a ‘complete product’. Just as Butland (granted he had a year at Cheltenham) yet he’s rated more than Carson and Green. Fully appreciate the 99% logic in what you’re saying. However, technically, I rate JWP more than Tom Cleverly.
Try to be a little more open minded.