Smirking_Saint

When we talk about precedents we need to evaluate like for like circumstances Swindon fielding not one but two ineligible players doesn’t equate to watching a training session The only two precedents there have been are Leeds and Canada women, and as such Id expect similar outcomes

Yeah but not much… its why its so fucking embarrassing, because the risk doesn’t weigh well against the reward At most we’d see if Hackney was fit… thats about it, maybe penalty or set pieces at best.. its just not worth this aggro at all

I think if it has this much of an impact then you’d see two things happening.. 1. Every club would be doing it to gain an advantage, you’d see drones etc not a 17 yr old with a nokia and a clipboard 2. Training grounds would be completely locked down The fact the above isn’t happening tells me immediately that its not a big deal as far as advantage is concerned

He’s not part of the process

As much as Id love it to be, I find it completely implausible that this is a set up, if it is it’s absolutely batshit IMO, he was there, probably as instructed by the analysts, and thats it We’ll be fined or points deducted next time we’re in the championship and thats it

Everyone spies outside of the 72 hour window, I expect everyone tries inside it too Its a non story

Both GKs are shite, I was wrong that we can carry them into next season, but a lot of that is because of how frail defensively we are which means both of our naff GKs have to face too many shots Baz is getting hammered for last night, and he did flap at it, but lets not let Stephens and THb off the hook, that run should be tracked, we shouldn’t be asking a keeper to come out for that really Its just indicative of how bad we are this year, nobody takes responsibility anywhere

The fact that Stephens, despite saying there was no issues, was dropped/injured shortly after this tells me this was us

On this Season, I think most managers would be happy with our squad going into this year, comparatively to the other teams So in summary Still has absolutely failed

Downes, Jander, Charles are all top level CMs at this level GK I agree with, although I think if we are functioning at all defensively we get away with it No.9 is a problem, absolutely, we wasted so much money there instead of signing anyone with any pedigree and with all of them the best is probably Archer and we seem to utilise him atrociously

Im not really sure what Blackmore is on about if Im completely honest, and unfortunately Ive lost any access I used to at the club but Rasmus was previously quite involved, and was then sidelined at the same time Kraft was ditched Kraft, I believe, was heavily in favour of not replacing Wilcox, and was a decision backed by Parsons Rasmus’ current role is player exits and the overall multi club strategy… and Id say he is actually doing ok on that front, but he does fit as the arrogant ‘thinks he knows more than he does’ statement Overall I think SR and Spoors has actually done ‘ok’ enough this year, they made good signings, unfortunately signing Downs and Stephens contract are a huge detractor of their summer but not sure hiw much involvement Spoors had, if he was involved its fucking awful The signing of Still, as crap as he is, Id still say in the interest of balance looked a good appointment at the time, he was a well respected coach and was courted by some decent clubs… unfortunately hindsight tells us, for whatever reasons that he is just not up to it

Parsons and Rasmus are a problem

Can this narrative just die… Will Still isn’t being told to play a 5 atb, thats just complete shite In fact… if he’s being instructed to play a certain way, it still points to him being a terrible manager as he hasn’t installed any vision into us whatsoever And the last point.. why would Spoors sign players to suit a 4231 and then push Still into playing 5 atb ? It makes no sense SR are shit enough on their own to not need made up nonsense about tactical interference

Genuinely have no idea what he was trying to do He achieved nothing, if anything he took us backwards

You’ve misinterpreted me, he is clearly a very good ‘coach’ as he managed to get the players playing a very specific way almost completely on instinct Thats in the same way as Pochettino came in and managee to coach very advanced pressing triggers quickly That is the sign of good ‘coaching’, what you’re alluding to, i think, is the difference between a good coach and a good manager… Poch was both, Martin was an awful manager

You can all laugh at this but he hasn’t Im all for fucking him off, met him, hate him… but he’s in Turkey This was a Parsons/Spors appointment Alot of you guys like to latch onto stuff that’s not relevant tbh

He’s had nothing to do with it though

Genuinely no idea.. but I got sucked in by it

He has to go… I don’t know what his gameplan is ? What his identity is ? Its just 11 men on the pitch for me, nothing else, I can’t see any evidence of any actual coaching, any motivation, any tactical plan Say what you want about Martin, he was stubborn but he was a very good coach (ok it didn’t work) and his players knew what he wanted. Even Juric you could see what he wanted I genuinely couldn’t tell you what our gameplan is Its awful (copy of my post from the match thread as its relevant here)

He has to go… I don’t know what his gameplan is ? What his identity is ? Its just 11 men on the pitch for me, nothing else, I can’t see any evidence of any actual coaching, any motivation, any tactical plan Say what you want about Martin, he was stubborn but he was a very good coach (ok it didn’t work) and his players knew what he wanted. Even Juric you could see what he wanted I genuinely couldn’t tell you what our gameplan is Its awful

Streams anyone ?

In fairness thats the one position he can moan about today Its him or Downs

No you whopper

Exactly this, I keep reading on here and listening to podcasters and YouTubers saying that the issue is 100% the players and the club, and Still needs more time I just don’t see it.. SR do a lot wrong, they are culpable for the majority of whats wrong with this club, but they bought well imo (outside of a striker, thats 100% criminal), we have a first 11 that rightly, on paper, should be challenging comfortably We keep hearing the players have relegation hangover.. well it was only really Manning and Armstrong from Blackburn that played significantly last year, we’ve seen a large rotation of players and why has Still not had a positive impact ? For me the issue is Still… we’re 12 games in and he still clearly doesn’t know his best 11, still finding his best formation and quite bizarrely still dropping the marquee signings he made in the summer Im not blaming SR in this instance for hiring Still.. I do think he was a good appointment, on paper, at the time… but clearly it’s not worked and for me doesn’t look like it will

Sack him before the 90