UpweySaint

Yes and No. Terrible answer but the right one. I'd suggest our record with young players and our dedication to try and bring anybody good enough into the first team set up sets us apart from a number of other clubs. Not many players are one club men anymore, that includes with the biggest clubs, but I should think that if we do things right we can get a lot of our youngsters for some of there better years before they move on for pastures new for large transfer fees that can continue to keep the academy ticking over and allow for the purchase of the occassional established player for the young lads to learn from (if even AL has said it's great learning from Ramirez imagine what the likes of JWP etc must think?) ..

Good shout on yoshida. Looked assured today. Only slight niggle, his clearances were dropping short now and then. Not exactly a beast of a cb but hopefully, given time, the backroom staff will work there manage and he can bulk up a touch just so he has that touch of power all the best cbs have.

For me punch today. But everything he had on show and his movement, along with our entire front line, was class. Special mention to ramirez who's looking better every game, his close control with the ball is a joy to watch. But again with most on here good displays all over the park and from the man on the side

Form temporary class permanent etc ... sure he still has it somehwere. But for me not match fit and hasn't looked that sharp. If we're going to have a keeper we're unsure of it only follows that we have the young one with potential (though it must be said gazza had a good game today!)

That will do! A big performance and, the best bit, we looked solid at the back. Smiles all round. Punch motm for me and shaw looked more then comfortable, I didn't think he'd be ready to step up but so glad to have been proved wrong. COYR

Loving the fluidity of our front four. Punch especially looks class today, causing them so many problems when he cuts inside! Lets hope we can keep it up and not sit too deep. Fancy a second goal and we can put the game to bed, if not i'l proceed to panic up until the final whistle!

Be more interested in their line up really, with the ammount of injuries they should hopefully look a little makeshift

In an ideal world yes. Would love to have him with the dev squad or even loaned out under less pressure but, with boruc and kd as the other two choices, i'd stick with him. Do agree with sentiments on other posts about keeping being worth a good deal of points, I remember Niemi keeping us in game after game which I dont see any of our current choices doing ...

Ok fair point, perhaps I should've been clearer with what i meant, the defence look more organised with him behind them. I dont have a panic attack at every corner or set piece. I might be being naive but I think gazza has plenty of potential to be a solid number one for years to come, once he shakes off the mistakes and works on his positioning. If boruc can come in and do a job right away then that'd be lovely but so far I don't think he's shown it.

Ok I admit I was edging around the swansea game, he had at least partial blame for that one, but Boruc hasnt exactly shown much of his stated quality so far. Gazza's distribution (minus the one obvious example!) has been good and his command of the box has been okay.

Football can do whatever it likes so long as we get three points, a win would be a massive result for us, two on the bounce would do wonders for belief (I hope!)

Honestly, no idea. My preference would be for gazza, seems to communicate well with the defence and hasnt had any calamaties, the odd mistake here and there but that goes for the bulk of our squad ...