Define, in legal terms, 'the purest of evil'. What test has to be made ? How does that test get written down such that lawyers and judges understand it, and such that it can be robustly challenged on appeal.
What if you get a case, as with the Teresa de Simone and Lesley Mulseed murders, or the Guildford & Birmingham pub bombers, where, on the balance of the evidence submitted to the courts, it is quite clear that the perpetrators have been found guilty of 'foul' or 'depraved' crimes, and there may well even be accompanying calls for the death penalty to be re-instated, ( as happened with the Mulseed case ). Such a case would probably come close to 'passing' your test.
Problem is, with all those cases, evidence was either suppressed, altered, or fabricated. How does your 'test' ensure that ALL the relevant evidence is brought to light at the trial, and not up to 27 years later ? ( Which presumably would be about 26 years too late to save the innocent convict ).