hypochondriac

You didn't clarify your answer stop deflecting. Is your answer to the question of what the definition of a woman is that there is no definition? That's different from the answer you gave earlier where you said that you weren't refusing to answer and that a definition did exist but it was more complex than the definition I had.

The info in the public domain makes it likely the dsd in question is 5-ARD which is the same condition that caster semenya has. In male foetuses internal testes are formed and produce testosterone (hence the raised testosterone levels that got the banned in the first place) but the extra step to another hormone is missing so external male structures aren't formed

So your answer to what the definition of a woman is is that there is no definition? Seriously?

Reports online suggest that the person in question has testicles and XY chromosones. Someone with testicles and XY chromosones is a biological man regardless of what DSD they possess that may give them an outward appearance of a woman. Do you want to help out colinjb? He seems to have difficulty providing the definition of a woman just like you have.

Interesting that you're asking me questions yet you can't or won't provide a definition of a woman. What is it about it that you find so difficult? You don't have to deflect, just answer the question. Can't be that difficult surely?

Was Pinder the model?

Hold on you're saying a definition isn't possible now? Or you could provide me with a "more educated" definition but are choosing not to? You're suggesting it does me no credit because I asked you for a definition of a word? Asking for a definition is wrong because that isn't providing enough nuance? Eh?

Maybe. Still not a fan. She's brilliant, her race isn't relevant.

Worth noting that you call me wrong in the manner of a biologist abd an idiot yet you can't even provide a definition of a woman...

Was great. Loads of our gold medals have been quite dramatic.

No Colinjb. For the sake of argument I was agreeing with you telling me that my definition was simplistic. You're just making yourself look silly now. I'm giving you the opportunity to give me what your definition is seeing as you believe mine is simplistic and you're doing everything you can not to give one. Let's be honest it's because you either don't have a definition of or you know that anyone you do have will make yourself look silly. What's your definition?

You're not refusing to answer but you haven't answered? You've told me what it's not which is that it's not black and white or simplistic but I still haven't had an answer of what it is. Come on Colinjb surely it's not that difficult to provide a definition? What is a woman?

Sounds to me like you're refusing to answer. Can't be that difficult to answer surely? Fair enough it's more complex than my simplistic worldview so what is the definition then? Educate me.

What's the answer then?

What is a woman?

Assume you'll be advocating for an X on passports. Clown world.

Not sure it's true but if it is he could well have been radicalised by online material or from a migrant for all we know so it very much coukd be an imported issue. Not convinced this is correct in this case though like I said. The police wouldn't have a reason to lie about it not being terrorism related because it would just come out if it was and the reaction would be worse.

Incorrect as usual. I was talking about a narrative from different media outlets and separately I was also talking about labour which is relevant because they are the party in power who recently did a big press conference to talk about the far right.

What a shame that someone uses their moment of triumph to try to divide along racial lines. It's such a peculiarly American thing. I don't think you'd see the same from a British athlete.

What is a woman?

Yes. A biological male who describes themselves and is described by others as a girl because outwardly they present as one.

What is a woman?

Yes. They look female but are biologically male. Sorry it upsets you.

Who mentioned gender? Also human beings are not turtles or frogs.