S-Clarke

That's how I see it, I've never questioned their intentions as I think they're pretty aligned on progressing us given the money they've invested, it's just their execution of pretty much every major decision has been awful. Had they got the big decisions right (probably starting with the Jones appointment), and continued to put the money in, we'd have been in a good place imo.

There has been a lot of criticism over SR, and rightly so, they've been awful.....but the one thing I can hold them in good light for are the sales and what we get for players. £50-60m for Lavia, 35-40m for Tino, £35m for JWP, £20-25m for Tella, £15-20m for Sullemana(!!!!!!). So we're never short changed or pushed around by selling clubs, not sure where that view has come from. I have full confidence that they'll get top, top dollar for both Dibling and Fernandes - if not, they'll stay. Simples. The entire model of their operation is a sell-to-profit setup, so this is one thing they have to be good at - and they are.

I guess he's got form for shirking off, as he did mid-season when his boyfriend was sacked. I hope that's not the case again and he can get his head down, but if there is the remote possibility that he's skulking around then we've got to shift him. He's not that important to us that a good scouted replacement wouldn't be able to fill.

Why would any decent team want Suguwara after last season though? Weird. I have no idea what any top outfit would have seen last season that would make them think ''Yes, that's the guy I want playing for me in the Champions League" He's got a hell of a lot to prove.

Yes, using 3 may be a good opportunity to extract the most out of the options we have. I've never felt comfortable with Stephens in a 3 though, he's even more confused about his role in that sort of setup. There is part of me that just wants to return to a normal back 4 though.

...

We built around him and Lallana for years, and he just sotted in like a glove to what we were doing - but going to another team, without a similar structure he was shown up sadly. He was never the most physical or mobile of players, but we helped shield him from that with Hammond/Fonte through the lower leagues and Wanyama/Fonte after promotion. He went to Utd and then Everton to be their '6' out on his own, but that was never his game. He needed presence alongside and around him.

Oh yep good point, sorry you'll have to forgive me for forgetting him I'll update it with him.

I wouldn't be against keeping Wood, but it just feels one too many. THB, Edwards, Quarshie, Stephens, Sanda and then Wood (I forgot to put Sanda above). I think Wood will be the sacrifice to get the numbers down. I don't think we'll keep either Matty or Tyler, but we need to use the money we get to entirely revamp our attack (wide, 10's etc). I'd even go as far as saying I feel we're a little short in CM, if Charles is injured or Downes, we're back to Smallbone trying to be a pivot again. It's going to be busy!

100% gone either sold or Loan. Kamaldeen Sullemana - Atalanta - £15M Paul Onuachu - Trabzonspor- £6m Aaaron Ramsdale - Newcastle - Loan £4m Fee Jan Bednarek - Porto - £6.5m Sam Amo-Ameyaw - Strasbourg - £8m Kyle Walker-Peters - West Ham - Free transfer Joe Lumley - Bristol City - Free Transfer Juan Larios - Loan - Cultural Leonesa Likley to leave imminently: Samuel Edozie - £8m (Strasbourg) Tyler Dibling - £35-45m (Everton) Players we are looking to move on soonish: Joe Aribo (Interested parties in Turkey) Armel Bella-Kotchap (Interested parties in Germany) Charlie Taylor (No idea) Nathan Wood (Surplus of defenders, club open to a loan apparently) Rumours circulating, club want to keep - these may become live towards the end of the window: Mateus Fernandes (Everyone in Europe wants him apparently) Taylor Harwood-Bellis (Some tentative links to Porto and WHU a few weeks ago - unlikely to go I think, but one to watch) Signed: Damien Downs - £5-6m Joshua Quarshie - 3.4m Players looking certain to stay: Alex McCarthy Gavin Bazunu Ronnie Edwards Jack Stephens Ryan Manning Wellington James Bree Yuki Suguwara Shea Charles Will Smallbone Flynn Downes Ross Stewart Adam Armstrong Ben Brereton-Diaz Cameron Archer Ryan Fraser Joachim Kayi Sanda Jay Robinson

Exactly that - it's not about people not liking him or trying to gang up on him personally (like a certain poster against Parsons). We just want the best for our team, that's all. And we know that Bazunu is not the best option for our team, it's really that simple. I don't want to 'make do' with someone who has failed in his 2 full seasons for us.

It's not about the howlers, I've said that. He's a strange keeper in that you cannot name a huge amount of howlers he makes (but he has made some), but on the flip side you can't really name any match winning or game saving saves he makes. As others have said, from a pure spectator POV and not on stats, you are often sat there after a goal went in and wondering ''should he have got to that?' - for one or two, yeah...debatable, but when pretty much every goal leads to those questions then you've really got to believe your gut. There's something not right there. The stats just backup what we've all seen to be honest. He lets in goals he should saved, not howlers per say, but a decent/capable keeper would probably pull of a 'great save' to keep it out. He doesn't seem capable of 'great saves', which is why he'll never really amount to much and why he shouldn't be front and centre for a promotion bid in any uncertain terms.

I watched him with my own eyes, and so did a lot of other people. I know what I saw every week to be honest, the stats just backed it up. So that's that really. I'll respect your view.

We're at that moment in the contract lifecycle really. The 2 year mark is predominantly the point where football clubs either extend or sell. We clearly want to extend, but he doesn't - so as a club, protecting our asset and ensuring we get as much profit as we can, I can see why we wouldn't just put out a blanket 'not for sale' message on him. With the advent of PSR and all that rubbish, Dibling would present pure profit - 100% profit, no sell on to pay anyone, no transfer fee still being paid - it's just all our money, straight onto the balance sheet. That gives us so much more flex in the market. Leave it a year, we may go up but we end up in a position where he commands maybe 15-20m - we're then a PL club with £15m in the bank to try and replace him with, whilst upgrading the rest of our team. Alternatively, we stay down, he still leaves - again 15m. Doesn't go as far. If he doesn't want to sign it's the right time. If he still had 3 or 4 years left, then I'd expect the club to shut the door on it and tell him to get his head down - but I think we've got to be sensible about it really. Get as much as we can, and allow us to evolve this squad away from what it is. It would have been good for him to be part of it, like the Adkins years, but football has changed - it'll never happen like that again.

I do think people overestimate some of our players, especially when you put us up against a Leicester or an Ipswich (in current guise). Downes, Charles, THB, Edwards, Archer, Armstrong, I'll give you as a good basis of a talented Championship team who are proven and hardened at this level (there's a lot more to it than names on the paper though) Beyond that cohort I'm really not sure we have much beyond mid-table at best. Suguwara needs to show a lot to prove that he's capable, Downs and Quarshie are still really unproven. Stewart hasn't played regular football for 3 years, and BBD does not fit our team. (imo) So to be competitive for the Top 2, I think we need two wide players, a 10 (or 2, one who could also cover CM), a new GK and better cover at RB (someone to really push Suguwara). 5-6 players isn't asking too much I don't think, but they all need to be immediate starters, not 'pet projects'. The level of the squad needs to be lifted as the gap between the first team and the rest is way too big right now. We do need to shift out quite a few to free the squad space though, so I just hope we can do it. We'll buy 100%, I'm not worried about that, I just hope we go far enough as you cannot underestimate how bad last season was - a few of the players still rotting around in the squad simply do not deserve a chance to play for us again. There is lots of work to do.

Even from a standing start, if we kept our team intact from last year, ditto them....they were still a whole 10+ points better than us in the PL last season. There was already a gulf there, and that was without the sales going on this year. Equally Ipswich were a whole 10 points clear of us too. Honestly, you just cannot underestimate how disgusting we were last season. We have to really pull off an incredible last few weeks to be in the convo for Top 2.

How do Chelsea keep doing this? Their failed signings keep generating either profit or get sold for net, so they keep making mistakes but never seem to lose out. It's crazy. Based on his impact last year, he shouldn't be going for anything north of £15m really. There's no way he's still worth what they paid.

We did, but I will also stand by the opinion that it was in spite of Bazunu. I truly believe had he not been injured, we'd have been knocked out in the playoffs. We won a lot of games because of our firepower, making up for the lack of defensive stability we had. Of course that was also down to our style, but we also ran the risk of any shot against being a goal. We let in 64 goals, or along those lines - for a promoted side that is horrendous. The defenders in Bednarek and THB were good enough to be stronger than they were, but the feeling I had is that any shot on target went in - and that was illustrated by the statistics at the end of the season, which had Bazunu bottom of the table on expected goals against by some distance. He didn't prevent any, he actually let in something like 10 or 11 more than he should have. He's a funny goal keeper because there aren't many absolute 'howlers' he drops, but there are also not really any game changing saves he makes. Teams know that if you get a shot on target and he's in goal, it will more than likely go in. That could be in part due to technical limitations in his game, or more to do with mentally in-game. It's probably a bit of both to be honest. Obviously I'm not a fan of his, but I don't want this to seem like some sort of personal crusade against him - I'm just speaking out because I'm frustrated by the acceptance of mediocrity, not just by fans, but by the club. The ruthlessness I wished for has not yet transpired, if you also add the Stephens contract into that. I respect peoples support for him, but I just feel it's a little misplaced that's all.

The Chuba Akpom deal is turning into a bit of a saga. Birmingham thought they had it wrapped up, then in nipped Boro. But now, Ipswich have jumped to the head of the queue. All 3 have agreed loan deals, now Ajax have left it to the player. Good signing for whoever gets him, getting on a bit though. Although he's guaranteed impact, rather than a 'young and hungry to improve' type we like to target.

Isn't there already a thread for all this? But as we're here, Vinicius Jr, Isak and Rodri.

West Ham/Everton and those sorts are the levels of clubs that will be after our players nowadays. It illustrates just how much we've dropped off in the last 6-7 years. That's what happens under awful management and disjointed ownership, but this is our new reality. We're small fish to those lower half PL sides now and will be for some time to come.

He's definitely done something to you personally, some weird bias going on between you and Parsons.

The feeling I've got with PSR over recent years, is the more you cheat the rules the better you become and get away with it. They'll probably sell off their women's team to generate income to offset it. Their stadium revenue will also fill some of the gaps. It seems as if you abide by the rules and keep your finances in check, like us, you're held back and inevitably regress and get kicked out of the league. If we ever get back up I couldn't care less about PSR - just go for it, spend, breach the rules. Who cares.

Rejected, but likely to be accepted at some point shortly I'd imagine. We're at the final negotiation stages, usually played out in the media with a good few days lag. It'll only take another 4-5m up front and they'll have a deal.