Well, it's a matter of opinion really. I would prefer a youngster learning the trade than an old dog who never learned new tricks and who is now so slow. As to Boruc, very true, we have no way of knowing, but you'd like to think our transfer people might have looked into it before opting for him. Or maybe not. Whatever is the case, we need yet another new keeper, which is something many on this board have been saying for around 2 years. Which is a bit rubbish.