James

Clattenberg you ****

JWP on, every time we do this we seem to lose all attacking threat

Why are we so **** in the final third?

He would have done, I just don't get what AL has done to deserve walking in against an in form Punch

Terrible by Adam

Bloody hell yoshi

Would keep Jos he looks ok and effective vs holt

Pilkington off

JRod playing well. We should get yosh Off he's looking like a bit of a liability

For the last 2 minutes....

Stupid foul yoshida

Looks atrocious already

Maya is just terrible at RB

Quelle Surprise. One of these days you will say something sensible.

I'm sorry, but if that is your 'constructive criticism' then you clearly do not go to games. Muscling bigger more physical players off the ball and winning headers against the odds are two of his greatest strengths. Did you actually watch the Man City game?

Still makes your point incorrect though. We played ****e against Wigan then outplayed Man U. Next time you want to make a dig at someone for taking a positive out of a likely defeat get your facts straight.

The Wigan game came first last time, so no not like that.

"Unrealistically bidding"...arrogant scousers. I suppose they didn't want Gaston or Forren then?

Gaston is quite clearly a fantastic player. Was brilliant against Arsenal and dictated things against Newcastle. He is a passenger in away games I agree. For some to say he should be dropped or that he hasn't shown himself as one of our best players in any game this season is sheer lunacy. But then half of these "critics" probably don't even watch the games

Shaw was awesome, so was punch. JRod played so well too

I reckon JRod will start. Hopefully that doesn't mean no Gaston

Taken off on a stretcher as a precaution?!

Maybe, although even today he cost us at least one goal with some terrible defensive/positional play. Don't get me wrong I think he is a great player but not quite there defensively at times. Got absolutely murdered at Stoke as well.

How can you even make a statement about our transfer activity 5 days into the window? That is completely ridiculous. And before you start, no our activity in the summer was not poor. You stated that we are 'so going down' I would argue that in making that statement, you have seen enough in all our performances to make a prediction that relegation is inevitable...yet at the same time you are trying to say that the same team, should have beaten a team chasing the top 4. I would suggest that a team that 'should' have beaten one of the top 4 therefore 'should' beat a lot of the teams lower down the table hence doing enough to at least give them a chance of staying up...but of course you don't think like that. And as for a thumping being a 'return to form' we haven't been thumped or outclassed like this at any point in the season other than at the Emirates..in all others we have at least been competitive and had a chance of getting something. In case you hadn't noticed, we are unbeaten in 4 in the league, a run which included difficult trips to stoke and fulham and a tricky home game with Arsenal (oh but of course that counts for nothing as we are clearly going down). It is no wonder nobody on here takes you seriously.

Should have beaten Arsenal yet we aren't good enough and are 'so going down'...nothing like consistency eh?