Jump to content

hypochondriac

Subscribed Users
  • Posts

    46,280
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by hypochondriac

  1. Not relevant and we've been through this all already. We did the crime, got caught and were punished for it. Personally I think the punishment was harsh but I can also see why they did it.
  2. It's not further punishment. Let's say hypothetically that we had sacked him in the summer. If he had received a football ban for six months, no one would be saying how unfair it is and how we had been punished already because it would be nothing to do with us. The fact it will affect us if he gets a ban is a choice we have made and it shouldn't affect the outcome.
  3. The reason it worked is because sadly we were bang to rights and had committed the crime. Going to the media to say we have been punished already is pointless. Tonda hasn't personally been punished yet and the fact it damages the club is entirely our choice for not sacking him. And the whining from Parsons about local businesses losing money and the money we lose in legal fees is silly. We did it and the local businesses should be mad at the club and Tonda for spying and costing us the chance of promotion. I'd really rather not be dragging this all up again but the club have decided it's a good idea.
  4. Right but if we felt that was sufficient there is no need to run to the media prior to the verdict.
  5. If we has to do an interview I'd have focused on precedent with Bielsa and the amount of time it has taken. Instead we talk about being punished already which is an irrelevance.
  6. How are they? The club and Tonda said their piece months ago and these interviews have said nothing new. Why feed the media machine and give the BBC the news it wants to throw it all out their again? What do we have to gain?
  7. I'm sure our lawyers will have been making that point at the hearing. Is a Dan Roan interview released three days before the hearing really going to change their minds if they're set on a ban?
  8. Just going to drag it all up again and we aren't going to get any sympathy. Why speak out? I'd love to know which crisis management firm advised them to do it and for what purpose.
  9. Yes I know but if they have actively been looking for new managers then the suggestion is that they are expecting him to go. Looking at it there isn't evidence they have actually done that, Roan just asked the question.
  10. Grasping at straws but maybe their new high priced legal team have suggested this was a good thing to do to put some pressure on the FA prior to Thursday?
  11. Silly headline. There's no suggestion that we have looked at other managers. Having that in the headline suggests that we have done that but have denied doing so.
  12. Not doing an interview wouldn't have really cost them anything.
  13. Where has the suggestion come from that we've sounded out potential new managers?
  14. My guess is they have some sort of indication of what it may be and it's probably not good news. If it was all OK then why do interviews prior to the verdict? The only answer is damage limitation.
  15. Simon Jordan said it and we know he had been speaking directly to Gibson because he rang him live on air!
  16. That is slightly looking at things with hindsight though. In the immediate aftermath many treated it as a joke and didn't think expulsion was the most likely outcome. Including allegedly Middlesbrough where Gibson apparently found it hilarious initially.
  17. Nothing like that was ever mentioned by the FA though and delegated to the intern does not state that this was done by Eckert directly. Ultimately he is responsible but the distinction still matters.
  18. I assume they mean the level of planning and coordination involved (like dressing up in Eastleigh training gear) as opposed to just rocking up and someone sending some footage to SFC from the training.
  19. What odds Peretz injuring himself in Israel and Ramsdale coming back in for the fishy few?
  20. Alfie House seemed quite clear on the Total Saints Podcast yesterday that it was the three instances of spying that he was charged with, nothing to do with behaviour towards other members of staff or interns.
  21. Presumably the announced punishment will be after the appeal. Look at Man City for example...
  22. True. He was actually charged with: Three breaches of FA Rule E3.1. Rule E3.1 is the FA’s broad misconduct rule. In essence, it says a participant must not act in a way that is improper, brings the game into disrepute, or involves threatening, abusive, indecent or insulting behaviour. It is alleged that he acted in an improper manner and/or brought the game into disrepute by directing and/or authorising the observation of opposition training sessions before Southampton played: Oxford United — December 2025 Ipswich Town — April 2026 Middlesbrough — May 2026
  23. I think that depends what they give him. I'm sure at least part of the delay is that we will have appealed and hopefully pushed back quite forcefully. Like you say though I never expected the original punishment so everything is up for grabs.
  24. Alfie house has confirmed that the three charges relate to the specific acts of spying on three occasions and nothing to do with conduct with staff.
  25. Yes I said that a few months ago but I can see an argument where they argue that Bielsa technically didn't break the rules because there were no rules to break. By breaking the rule now, you could argue that breaking the newly formulated rules themselves would constitute the bringing the game into disrepute charge. Not saying I agree with it but surely that's how it will be interpreted.
×
×
  • Create New...