-
Posts
46280 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by hypochondriac
-
What lines?
-
Absolutely bizarre that he'd rather be there than here
-
Come on you bastards tell us what we are looking at today.
-
Good post. And really you can argue about our punishment but clearly they didn't want this practice to ever happen again so from their perspective it's mission accomplished. That why I don't think they need to unnecessarily hammer Tonda because no one is going to be doing anything like this again unless they have a death wish. I know it's a punishment to him as an individual but if it was overly harsh it effectively punishes us too and they will know that prior to giving out the punishment.
-
As long as we don't see him signing a Liverpool shirt or trying to take out a full page goodbye in the echo I'll stay hopeful.
-
At least that suggests it's just a touchline ban.
-
This is great news if true. I assume it means Tonda stays as manager which is the main thing.
-
I think more than six games and we should be appealing.
-
People never learn and always read too much into preseason results and performances. I've seen saints play terribly in preseason and look quite good at the start of the season and vice versa. I really don't think it means much. We do need an alternative to Larin though.
-
Would a touchline ban include friendlies? Surely they will have to say something at the end of the game.
-
I know someone who knows people in the club and the message I got from him was that no one in the club is expecting a substantial ban. I know that doesn't mean much given the club never expected our previous punishment but maybe slightly reassuring.
-
Well it's not 4:30 so half an hour left!
-
Interesting. I wonder if our result has been released already and we are keeping it secret while we appeal?
-
That's what I just said. It will be interesting to see if anything like that is mentioned if we ever get to see the details of any ruling.
-
Fine then we agree. There is nothing that either of us can think of about this Tonda charge that is materially different from the Bielsa charge (other than the EFL rule break that you state is an irrelevance.) yet both of us accept that it is highly likely that he will receive a harsher punishment. Will be interesting to read the justification for doing so.
-
Bif if a nothingburger expecting anything today.
-
Rumours from Random Social Media Accounts
hypochondriac replied to Master Bates's topic in The Saints
Nothing on Alex crooks time-line. -
I'm aware. My question which you ignored earlier is in what way the breach from Tonda is different to the breach from Bielsa which would result in a much greater punishment than a warning?
-
No my point is that if what you claim is correct and that the breaking of the EFL rule is a total irrelevance then logically the only punishment that should be given to Tonda should be a warning because it's a less egregious breaking of their rules than Bielsa. If he gets more than just a warning - which at this point seems incredibly likely - then my question is how is it possible to have such a discrepancy in the sentencing between the two cases? How can there be such a disparity for a less serious breach of the same rule? Unless they are taking into account the breaking of the EFL rules or some other element that you can suggest to me. Not sure what's difficult to understand about that. I'm fully aware that the FA have not charged us for spying and was making the same point last week.
-
FFS. Point me to any of my posts where I said they did? You have even said yourself that it is likely that he will receive more than the warning that Bielsa got.
-
But surely the Bielsa warning is the precedent? What is in any way different other than Tonda breaking the EFL rule and having engaged in spying to a lesser degree than Bielsa?
-
Hopefully it's less but even five games would make no sense if we are to follow your logic about the EFL rule break being an irrelevance.
-
That's my point. Had Bielsa been harshly treated under the same rule break then you could say Tonda would be bang to rights and deserves harsh treatment to a greater degree. What Bielsa did was actually worse and the only difference between the two that I can see is that Tonda broke the EFL rule (unless there is something proven around bullying but I don't believe he has been charged with that and nor do I believe that it actually happened.)
