James

Are you going to bang on about Puel all season? He was ****e, if MP turns out to also be ****e then it won't make Puel any better. Reed is at fault here. We could have gone for Silva but we dithered and we should have freshened up our attack but instead we've been stockpiling centre halves (which, ironically, was what we should have been doing last January). Fact is, the rot had set in during RK's second season where we played some awful stuff until we went on a one of a kind Mane/Long inspired run to sixth. Continuing to flog our Crown Jewels, replacing them with average, cheap players (compared to the current going rate) and leaving glaring holes in the squad every window was always going to catch up with us and I do worry we will be dragged in at the bottom this year. Even Brighton have started scoring.

This would be great.

Watford look like Barca compared to us. Not good enough.

He won't last. If he carries on like this it won't be long.

We might as well put a sack of spuds in our net. It's about as much use as Forster.

Gabby off. Oh do **** off. Not sure MP knows what he's doing here.

Got to say, not impressed by MP so far. He hasn't delivered anything we were told he would. Shambles.

Game over. See what happens when you have a shot? ****ing rubbish. A lot to do for MP.

Let's get one of Long or Austin on but leave Gabby on too.

Tadic for JWP. Don't understand that at all. Must be watching a different game to MP.

But the clappers will tell you that we've had a first class window. I've said it before, we are always a window behind in terms of rectifying obvious deficiencies in the squad. We can't score and we did nothing to try and improve that over the summer.

Has JWP touched the ball yet?

So hiring Poch was a brilliant move by the sporting department but signing Gaston (who had, lest we forget, excelled at the Olympics that summer and who we were all excited about) was an atrocious decision attributable only to NC? Seems pretty convinient to apportion good and bad footballing decisions to suit your narrative. Cortese was great for us, I was gutted when he left and I honestly think we'd have qualified for the CL had he stayed. Reed's big problem is that summer when we sold everyone. Regardless of what's been achieved since the fans will never 100% trust him following that.

This. Stephens is good on the ball but not great at actually defending.

I must have imagined that absolute screamer against Sunderland in the cup. Beautiful control and technique, we've got very few players capable of that. Hardly the mark of someone who is "woeful". The guy clearly has talent, whether he can translate it into consistent performances in a top league is another matter but to write him off as you have at this stage is incredibly harsh.

7/10 for me too. Still short up front but brilliant to have not sold anyone significant and to have recruited two quality players.

Sums up my thoughts exactly. Another window closes with another glaring shortage in the squad. Has happened in the last three windows now.

It's not about the specific player but this could be the Fonte situation for this year. We've sold JRod, loaned Gallagher and clearly the board feel we need someone else so have gone for Vietto. If we've left it until deadline day and have been gazumped then it's not great. For me it's not about the identity of the player that will be disappointing it's the fact we clearly know we are short and have gambled on getting someone in on the final day.

There's surely no chance we'd let Long go without getting someone in is there? We'd be one injury away from a very serious problem. That's my issue with the window, I'm delighted with the players we have brought in but our main issue is that we cannot score goals. We had a limited number of options last year (and I think we all agreed we were a player short before Gabbi joined) yet we've let two strikers go this summer and are just as limited as we were last year. I think that the striker/forward issue not being addressed is a legitimate criticism this window (which may yet be rectified) irrespective of who else we've brought in.

I reckon it's Vietto.

Can't deny he isn't a good player on his day though. I'd have him here for sure.

In isolation yes but given we massively messed up last summer it wouldn't have been too hard to plug the gaps we left for ourselves.

Not really bedwetting when you say it would be stupid not to sell is it? Would completely understand if we did sell but would be disappointed we hadn't done it earlier and reinvested a bit.

It's inevitable as we always sell and if there's a risk he won't play for months it would be stupid not to.

Agreed but arguably this window only rectifies the abysmal window we had last summer and doesn't address the problems identified last window. My prediction is that we will continue to struggle to score until Jan when we finally do something about it. We always seem a window behind. Can't argue with the players we have brought in though.