On the surface, it seems like a good idea and it's a bit of a crowd pleaser to boot. However, I have an underlying belief/philosophy that politicians aren't very good at spending/redistributing other people's money wisely/efficiently. How about a more direct/targeted approach instead? Say, free petrol/diesel for families that are struggling? Probably a nightmare to administer/implement such an idea, and no doubt open to abuse, but I'm not convinced giving politicians access to a few billion quid via a windfall tax would actually solve anything. #thinkingoutloud