Jump to content

Dirty Southern &@€$#}


Pilchards
 Share

Recommended Posts

The table isn't a very good measure of dirty play at all. We might have been guilty of most fouls, but we're way down the table in terms of the yellow and red cards and penalties scored against us, which would be the far more accurate measure of dirty play

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Actually the table to me shows exactly the opposite of what the OP thinks. It shows that we compete, without being dirty. yes we commit fouls, but they are generally not dirty fouls otherwise we would have more yellows and reds. I am quite pleased by this table, it makes me think that we are not the pushovers we have often been in the past. It also shows we are well-disciplined at the back only to have conceded 3 pens, and 1 of those was Oxo's at Posh which was shown clearly not to have been a pen (in fact 2 of them were in that game). well done Saints, competitive, well-disciplined and fair.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Actually the table to me shows exactly the opposite of what the OP thinks. It shows that we compete, without being dirty. yes we commit fouls, but they are generally not dirty fouls otherwise we would have more yellows and reds. I am quite pleased by this table, it makes me think that we are not the pushovers we have often been in the past. It also shows we are well-disciplined at the back only to have conceded 3 pens, and 1 of those was Oxo's at Posh which was shown clearly not to have been a pen (in fact 2 of them were in that game). well done Saints, competitive, well-disciplined and fair.

 

All good points. If you divide the total number of fouls by the number of bookings, that gives an idea of the proportion of fouls that are serious. So MK Dons, for example, have a low total of fouls (355), but around one sixth of these (60) resulted in bookings; they've also had nine players sent off, which is the highest except for Plymouth. In contrast, just over a tenth of our fouls have resulted in bookings - 51 from 478.

 

The third penalty we've conceded was Brighton at home, and that looked like a very poor decision to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Actually the table to me shows exactly the opposite of what the OP thinks. It shows that we compete, without being dirty. yes we commit fouls, but they are generally not dirty fouls otherwise we would have more yellows and reds. I am quite pleased by this table, it makes me think that we are not the pushovers we have often been in the past. It also shows we are well-disciplined at the back only to have conceded 3 pens, and 1 of those was Oxo's at Posh which was shown clearly not to have been a pen (in fact 2 of them were in that game). well done Saints, competitive, well-disciplined and fair.

 

This. Coupled with the fact that the amount of fouls probably tells you something about the amount of challenges that we are making during the game, which in turn would point to a high workrate level. It would also indicate that we are making the challenges in the 'right areas' of the pitch as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...