Saint Garrett

Neither Martina or Cedric are good enough to play in a top 10 prem side, we all wanted us to sign a decent RB this summer, it seems we've just signed another average one, but Pied looks an upgrade on these two.

Do they really need ANOTHER attacking midfielder? Bearing in mind we have what....1 in Tadic and possibly another in Davis.... They have: Ayew (ok yes injured) Feghouli Payet Antonio Lanzini Valencia Tore They brand themselves "The Academy of Football" - but when was the last time they brought through a player from their youth side....Noble/Tomkins are the only two I can think of and they must have made their debuts 10 years ago....! Reece Oxford is the only one they have right now but he doesnt get the chance to play.

Hmm, I do not rate Cedric at all, personally think hes very very poor. Martina did a job, but isn't very good. probably indifferent. Clasie...meh, paid a decent amount of money for him when he's arguably not that much better than Harry Reed. Hasn't held down a place in the team, Elia and Djuricic gave us a bit of attacking squad depth that we needed at the time, and as I went to Newcastle when Elia scored twice and gave me a great weekend, I quite liked him, quite liked his passion too.

Putting them into each of these categories.... Austin could go under bad, however he's not really been here long enough to be given that label yet. Clasie maybe unlucky to get into the "bad" category. Generally our best acquisitions are the ones around £10/12m which in this summers window is probably more like a £15/20m signing. Good: - LOVREN - WANYAMA - TADIC - PELLE - BERTRAND - FORSTER - LONG - *ALDERWEIRELD* - MANE - VAN DIJK Indifferent: - *ELIA* - *DJURICIC* - GARDOS - AUSTIN - *STEKELENBURG* - ROMEU Bad: - OSVALDO - *TAIDER* - JUANMI - CEDRIC - MARTINA - CLASIE - *CAULKER* N/A: - REDMOND - HØJBJERG - A.McCARTHY - PIED

He's pretty ****e but better than Cedric IMO. Two championship standard RB's.

He's way stockier IMO. Looks a talent, played well vs City the other night.

Said all summer he won't go, still can't see it.

It wasn't worded like that, it was worded as similar career path to Pelle....

Yep and they're still in £100m of debt! Somehow !!!

Sunderland look awful. Incoming 0-1 sat then...

Would take Phil Jones if Fonte does go, personally don't think he's going anywhere though.

Stanciu would be a decent signing, can't see him being a "squad" player if we bring him in.

We'll need width against these lot Forster Pied Fonte VVD Bertrand (Targett) Hoibjerg Clasie Redmond Davis Tadic Long

Thanks Guan....concerning that there is no rumours. I'm really concerned for us if we don't bring in a few.

Can't play Redmond as a CM, not going to happen, if he plays he plays as one of the strikers or as #10, and after bigging him up as a striker for the last month, not sure Puel will swallow his pride and play him anywhere else, or a different system for that matter...

Nonsense, or did we give Everton money for Mane?!

Don't think there is such a thing as FFP anymore?! Hence why Wolves are going to go and spent ca £20m on Talisca from Benfica. Would be great to hear from Guan or K,Billy...all very very silent.

You know Pied is a RB right? I'd play Pied or Martina. Cedric is poor.

Sounds like agent chat to me...

Time to see some rumours, we need additions badly, the Europa league could be an embarrassment at this rate

Both victims of the system, Davis is lost there, he needs to play between the lines and link play. Can't do that.

If its on Talksport then he's definitely not going there.

A RUMOUR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Is he? Pretty sure Benteke has gone for £27m+5m...(£32m) whereas Mane went for £34.5m+£4m... (£38.5m).

Any transfer rumours?! Would be nice for this thread to be kept to transfer rumours and chat....