Interesting read.Lets not forget how WGS is lauded for getting to a cup final.
AP was within seconds of actually winning the trophy.
A WHU fan I know locally was of the opinion that AP resented having the two Argie players thrust on him without prior agreement and that their introduction upset the dressing room.
As for Charlton,many managers have one club to tarnish their record - Clough at Leeds for example - where it simply does not work,or they may not be 'right' for the club in particular circumstances.
Sorry to say,that outside of Southampton,many football fans rate Red****t as an outstanding manager,success everywhere, apart from us, (albeit at a price...).