Matthew, you don't win an argument by changing tack every time somebody pulls you up on a point. You posted the opinion that a question on the existence or not of an entity was a binary choice, this was initially challenged by people claiming "I don't know" is a valid response to "Do you belive in God", to which you reiterated that a poll on such a question had to be binary. In response I posed the question on aliens, as positing that query is in exactly the same vein as your original.
You now are determining that we are discussing something that "exists" outside time and space, which has never previously been brought into the exchange.