Jump to content

Chez

Subscribed Users
  • Posts

    24,259
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Chez

  1. Likewise. Adding to your comments, he's a very erratic passer. One decent ball that makes him look like Morgan, then three or four **** ones that makes him look like Wanyama.
  2. Was there a better alternative? There are not loads of top class keepers available for a season loan or who would sign for us knowing Foster would replace them once fit.
  3. Targett has the first touch to make it, but right now the combination of being physically lightweight and not pacey makes him a weak point whenever he plays, which was all the time at the start of the season. For me a season out on loan to toughen up would have been the best thing for him. That said who would have covered Bertrand? It's not like we could have got a top class full back in for one season, or even half a season whilst Bertrand was recovering from injury. Which in a nutshell shows how tricky it is to manage a squad, which is exactly why I tend to taper any blame.
  4. as someone that gives Targett plenty of stick, I'd like to I concur with your assessment of Tadic. With the ball, pretty decent player (and to be honest the side struggles to keep the ball or create chances when he doesn't play), without it, pretty poor. Returning to the Caulker post, this is good news. I wasnt expecting a world beater, but I was surprised at just how slow he was, especially on the turn. Hopefully that will free up some wages for us to get another loan in ourselves.
  5. You are right, in recent times I have tried to avoid taking sides, lay overall blame at a doorstep or offered a solution. I am not sure I can offer answers, explanations or a way forward that hasn't been offered by other more knowledgeable posters. I don't know enough or feel there is a silver bullet. My comment about squad management was specifically about the left back situation, and for me the misevaluation of Targett in preseason as being good enough for the premiership, even as a back up, this season.
  6. Gotcha, in which case we are most definitely still playing the 'Southampton way' with RK at the helm.
  7. What way? What the **** does: play the Southampton way mean?
  8. Obviously the £2m grant provided by the football trust in 1995 to help pay for the new Fratton End and the other work required to turn **** Park into an all seater stadium wasn't enough, so they want another hand out.
  9. At the moment it almost does from me... We have taken a huge risk with Targett. We didn't sign a left back even though we knew Bertand was going to be out for a while, and IMO it backfired massively. Targett was a liability at the start of the season. He was incredibly weak and having him in the side totally unsettled the back four, had players covering his inadequacies and IMO cost us points. Thank god Bertrand got back reasonably soon. People are massively overgenerous with Targett,because he is young and has come through the academy. If we had spent transfer money on him, which as the youth development costs £2m is it a year supposedly, means we actually have, then he'd be slated right left and centre. IMO he is not ready yet and needs a season in the championship to toughen him up.
  10. Academy players maybe, but I'd of thought the young pros would be involved. If not in every session, certainly quite a fair bit. Targett for example has played a fair bit of under 21 football but must have been visible to RK. It would be interesting to get a definitive answer to this.
  11. I think you are rewriting history to suit your argueMent. He looked at home from the first minute of his first game. Physically and mentally he looked not only string enough to play, but actually to offer something positive to the side.
  12. How is it that teams at the bottom beat teams at the top? That happens all the time. That's football. If we had made the mistakes we made leading to the goals yesterday in that arsenal game the result would have been very different. The formation didn't lead to that terrible pass by Davis or save by Stek.
  13. Did Seager play in that game and if so how would you evaluate his performance and can you describe what sort of play he is? Does he has the strength to hide the ball up, speed to skin a defender, does he win headers, how is his first touch and movement? I see so many calls for him to get ten minutes at least, but does he even justify that?
  14. A lot of new faces that haven't been here a year, so a long list is never going to be possible, but Gazza and JWP have improved since this time last year. Also, how do you separate the effect of a loss of confidence from any improvements made to ability and performance through coaching? One more thing, do you expect senior players to get better every single year? Is Fonte for example meant to be better every single year because of good coaching? Form and confidence and team performance effect fans appreciation of a players performance and ability far more than coaching. Actually one more thing. Is it good coaching that has made Messi better? Coaches can only do so much.
  15. The Southampton way is just marketing tosh. How on earth can you base a clubs footballing philosophy around a single formation. Ok it makes sense for the under 21s to play in the same formation as the senior side, but RK must be able to by change his formation when he feels it is required.
  16. Oliver Burke at Forest is a genuine talent and exactly the sort of young attacking player that we are missing coming through our set up at the minute. Lewis Cook at Leeds is another player we should be looking at.
  17. Which others? The less we see of Targett the better. So it's basically Reed and Seager. I agree with you about Reed, but I've seen posts on here saying he's not done it at u21 level and therefore hasn't deserved to play ahead of Romeu and JWP. So that leaves Seager.
  18. This Seager lad better be good, because he has become the best young player ever on this forum. If he was a Shearer he'd of got his chance by now, but I suspect he's not. As with all young players they get a chance every day to shine on the training pitch. It's not all five a sides.They will have the chance to play against first team players in attack be defence and even full 11 vs 11 situations. If Seager is running Fonte ragged and smashing the ball past Forster etc., then RK will see that. Good players stand out.
  19. Yep. Play them, which is what Koeman did yesterday with Targett at left back and he got made to look a mug by Zaha.
  20. Agreed. That might point to good coaching, a great team work ethic and a large group of decent players. What the first team needs is one absolute top notch player to come out of the batch of youngsters. If you get a Shaw and 10 others not fit to lace his boots that's probably preferable.
  21. I thought Classie had an a good game yesterday. His passing was excellent, and I was especially impressed at the number of times he looked to play it forward to players between the lines. The other part of his game, the off the ball stuff such as closing down, getting goal side, tackling, hustling and winning second ball was much much better. He still can't win anything in the air of course, but he was much more effective. If we can add the right players around him, with some height, then he could be a good signing for us.
  22. The board gave Rodriguez an extra five years when it was unclear if he would ever make it back to his best, so who knows what they are thinking of doing with RK...
  23. You cant integrate youth into the first team if they are not good enough to get in the side. I'm not a fan of Koeman. Whether he is a good coach or not is hard to say. Only players can really tell you that. His eye for a player is certainly in question, but the more I see of Classie the more I like him and he was his big signing of the summer. It could be argued that he has shown too much faith in youth. Targett is miles off the level required in the top flight, yet he is second choice left back. JWP has his detractors, I personally think he has improved as this season has gone on, and he gets a lot of game time.
  24. Agree with pretty much all of that, except you evaluation of Targett. Even his throw ins were ****.
  25. Did it swerve at all? Only excuse I can offer.
×
×
  • Create New...