I'd like to see Puel given another season. We've had a good year, but not a brilliant year and we, as fans, have been spoilt recently.
The main reasons we aren't further up the table are:
1) We were painfully short of goals at the beginning of the season and that was made worse when our only goalscorer picked up a long-term injury. The lack of a goalscorer was proven to be the problem when we signed MG.
2) We sold our captain and solid CB in January without replacing him, only for our other CB (and best player) to pick up a long-term injury forcing us to play an academy youngster to get by.
none of the above are Puel's fault and I challenge you to find a manager that wouldn't struggle in the above circumstances.
Another top-half finish and a cup final that we should have won (thanks lino) given the rotten luck we've had this year means he deserves another season.