I'd keep Puel. The football's not great at the minute but the season's far from being a disaster. (Well, bar the Europa League.) If we finish 8th that's pretty much where we should be. The board need to back Puel with decent signings this summer. (One or two centre halves, holding midfielder, goal scoring midfielder and decent centre forward.) If they do decide its time for a new manager then if Rafa Benitez was available he'd be my choice too.