Frankie Bennett or Duncan Spedding?

[Dusic]

If we had to name one on the bench for the City semi final who would you go for?

Bennett is 57 now so would probs only manage a short cameo, Spedding a decade younger but was dreadful although like Sam Hoskins made the transition from Southampton failure to Northampton legend.

Will go for Bennett's experience for an occassion with potential to overwhelm.

 

 

[Gloucester Saint]

Any striker who hits such a wild shot at goal that it clears both tiers of the Milton Road End wins for me.

[Badger]

What's Michael Gilkes up to ? 

unfinished business and all that

[Football Special]

56 minutes ago, Dusic said:

If we had to name one on the bench for the City semi final who would you go for?

Bennett is 57 now so would probs only manage a short cameo, Spedding a decade younger but was dreadful although like Sam Hoskins made the transition from Southampton failure to Northampton legend.

Will go for Bennett's experience for an occassion with potential to overwhelm.

 

 

Neither, I'd have Peter Whiston 

[Dusic]

27 minutes ago, Football Special said:

Neither, I'd have Peter Whiston 

Yeah but you have to name one of Bennett or Spedding, as is stated.

[Football Special]

29 minutes ago, Dusic said:

Yeah but you have to name one of Bennett or Spedding, as is stated.

OK im in for Bennett , thought he'd be our Tony Daley 

[John D]

Bennett for me.  He'd be useful serving the drinks during one of those unofficial breaks mid half. 

[Green]

Frankie Bennett has form against Chelsea, I’d “tip” him to make a bigger impact in the final, so bench for City and then Chelsea in the final to open the scoring. 

[saintstowin]

I'd go for Duncan's brother Charlie in case it goes to extra time and we need his stamina.

[SNSUN]

Duncan Spedding was the first player I edited on CM 97/98 to have perfect 20 attributes and he was amazing. I forget why I chose him but maybe somehow I knew that nearly 30 years later this question would arise on a Saints forum and I could then say: I'll take the perfect attribute Duncan Spedding to rip City apart.

[SaintsLoyal]

chicken george

[benjii]

Frankie Bennett.

But I'll raise you a Cosimo Sarli.

[Pancake]

6 hours ago, SNSUN said:

Duncan Spedding was the first player I edited on CM 97/98 to have perfect 20 attributes and he was amazing. I forget why I chose him but maybe somehow I knew that nearly 30 years later this question would arise on a Saints forum and I could then say: I'll take the perfect attribute Duncan Spedding to rip City apart.

I went to school with him. Sound guy, clearly head and shoulders above the rest of our year at all sports. 

Edited Saturday at 14:31 by Pancake

[Toussaint]

On 18/04/2026 at 10:46, SaintsLoyal said:

chicken george

Chicken choker

[Dusic]

I have written to the club about this, haven't heard anything as yet.

Does anyone know of a way to get in touch with either of them assuming we get the go ahead? 

[swannymere]

Surely Fabrice Fernandes would be a better option? He would make the opposition dizzy watching him running in circles.

[St Louis]

54 minutes ago, swannymere said:

Surely Fabrice Fernandes would be a better option? He would make the opposition dizzy watching him running in circles.

The club dont like to use him in our Wembley games (see May '03), not one for the big occasions. Chris Baird potentially?

Edited 3 hours ago by St Louis

[St Louis]

Frankie Bennett certainly had the credentials.... and he knows how to deliver under pressure!

SOUTHAMPTON have agreed an initial fee of £10,000 for the Halesowen Town striker Frankie Bennett, a 22-year-old Birmingham hotel waiter.
https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/sport-in-short-football-1475189.html