Club form tells you he plays well in a team that is studded with players not legible to play for England. That's all. Rooney is every bit as involved in selection "due to image rights" as anyone else you may care to suggest. England players should be picked based partly on club form, but also their ability to fit in to the national side and make it a better side. This is why Senna played for Spain for years at the expense of Xabi Alonso and Cesc Fabregas. Not because he was technically a better player, just because he made Spain a better team. Rooney has not made England a better side since 2004. In fact, I would go as far to say he has made us a much slower, more pedestrian side than we would otherwise be in his last 2 World Cups. Unlike you, I am unwillingly the read in to his performances against the likes of Montenegro and Bulgaria in qualifying, which despite perhaps not being the worst in the world, certainly weren't that of an automatic, no-questions-asked starter.